Il faut le répéter, au risque de froisser le sentimentalisme moderne: L'économie politique se tient dans la région de ce qu'on nomme les affaires, et les affaires se font sous l'influence de l'intérêt personnel. Les puritains du socialisme ont beau crier: « C'est affreux, nous changerons tout cela; » leurs déclamations à cet égard se donnent à elles-mêmes un démenti permanent. Allez donc les acheter, quai Voltaire, au nom de la fraternité!
Chapitre IV des Harmonies Économiques, Échange
"We must repeat, at the risk of distressing modern sentimentalists: Political economy is restricted to the area that we call business and business is under the influence of self-interest. Let the puritans of socialism cry out as much as they will: "This is horrible; we shall change all this"; their rantings on this subject constitute their own conclusive refutation. Try to buy a printed copy of their publications on the Quai Voltaire, using brotherly love as payment!"
Chapter 4, Economic Harmonies, Exchange
Wednesday, August 26, 2009
The Quotable Bastiat
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Bastiat
Tuesday, August 25, 2009
National Shoe Care
If the government and only the government had had a monopoly of the shoe manufacturing and retailing business, how would most of the public treat the libertarian who now came along to advocate that the government get out of the shoe business and throw it open to private enterprise? He would undoubtedly be treated as follows: people would cry, “How could you? You are opposed to the public, and to poor people, wearing shoes! And who would supply shoes to the public if the government got out of the business? Tell us that! Be constructive! It’s easy to be negative and smart-alecky about government; but tell us who would supply shoes? Which people? How many shoe stores would be available in each city and town? How would the shoe firms be capitalized? How many brands would there be? What material would they use? What lasts? What would be the pricing arrangements for shoes? Wouldn’t regulation of the shoe industry be needed to see to it that the product is sound? And who would supply the poor with shoes? Suppose a poor person didn’t have the money to buy a pair?”
Murray Rothbard, For a New Liberty
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
8:16 AM
0
comments
Labels: Social Theory
Sunday, August 23, 2009
The Piedmont Economics Club
Holding dinner meetings at the Poinsett Club in Greenville, SC, the Club offers its members and their guests the opportunity to hear leading economists, financial analysts, journalists, and government policy makers.
The Club meets six to seven times a year, and always begins its meetings with a 6:00 pm reception and time of fellowship. This is followed by dinner and the speaker's presentation. A time for questions and reflection rounds out the club meeting.
In addition to promoting economic thought and discussion among its members and their guests, the Club seeks to enrich the teaching of economics at area universities. Faculty members at Clemson University, Furman University, and Wofford College enjoy a standing invitation to attend meetings as guests of the Club. The Club also hosts university students as guests.
Fall Programs for 2009-2010
September 8 – Susan Bies. Dr. Bies is former Governor of the Federal Reserve with a career career spent in academia, banking, and as member of key national financial policy organizations. Susan will share insights on the Fed, on activities that led to the 2007-08 financial collapse, and on future prospects for the economy.
October 7 – Robert Lawson. Dr. Lawson leads a center for economic freedom at Auburn University. Robert was the coauthor and project director for the first Economic Freedom Index of the World. He continues to be the leading world figure in measuring and analyzing economic freedom. Robert will discuss his work and what he sees happening to economic freedom around the world.
November 11 – Larry White. Dr. White is the Frederich v. Hayek Professor of Economics at the University of Missouri--St. Louis and a leading scholar in monetary history and policy. Larry has published widely on the relative merits of commodity money and is currently completing a book on history of economic thought. He will share ideas about money and the economy.
January 19 - Doug Woodward. Dr. Woodward is director of research and lead economic forecaster at the University of South Carolina's Moore College of Business. Doug is widely known for his work as a forecaster and for his research on economic development. Dr. Woodward will share his thoughts on the 2010 outlook for the nation, region, and state.
February 16. Robert Ariail. Robert Arial is a nationally syndicated editorial cartoonist. His widely published cartoons capture the essence of the risks and uncertainties of economic policies embraced by politicians. Robert will give a presentation on the history of cartooning and will show and comment on a sample of his artistic renderings
March 16. Susan Dudley. In December 2008, Susan Dudley ended a two-year stint as Director of the White House Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs. As the nation's regulatory czar, Susan oversaw the regulatory activities of the federal government. Susan will tell us about what is going on with regulation in the United States and beyond
Last Season’s Speakers
Michael Schermer -- The Mind of the Market: Evolutionary Economics
Karol Boudreaux -- Enterprise Africa: Can Capitalism Work in Africa?
Richard Ebeling -- Why the Specter of Communism is Still Haunting the World
Mark Vitner -- The Outlook for 2009
Scott Baier -- The Economic Council of Advisors
Gerald O’Driscoll -- Life after the Sub-Prime Mess
Bill Poole -- Monetary Policy Effects on Today’s Economy
Membership Information
Membership is open to all who are interested in the discussion of economic ideas, trends, and related topics. The membership fee for 2008-2009 is $475.00. Members may bring guests for a fee of $50.00. The regular guest fee is $85.00.
For more information, contact:
Piedmont Economics Club
PO Box 1805
Greenville, SC 29602
Sydney Taylor at sydney@canal-ins.com
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Meetings
Saturday, August 22, 2009
Bottom-Up
"The supreme example of bottom-up, rather than top-down, complexity is the market itself. As the economist Paul Seabright has written, the almost miraculous system by which he can go out and buy a cotton shirt on a whim — and expect the cotton grower, the weaver, the shirtmaker, the shipper and the retailer to have got it ready for him just when he enters the shop — is not planned or designed, it evolves. The top-down alternative does not have a great track record. Can you doubt that if the shirt industry was run by a National Shirt Service, there would now be queues, quotas and shortages?
Author Matt Ridley, "The Natural Order of Things." The Spectator (UK)
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Social Theory
Friday, August 21, 2009
Behavioral Economics
Here is a fascinating discussion of behavioral economics, or the story of how people behave outside of economic models. Useful for any business with employees, customers, or both.
Greg Davies on behavioral economics.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Social Theory
Thursday, August 20, 2009
Public Service

"The government of my country snubs honest simplicity but fondles artistic villainy, and I think I might have developed into a very capable pickpocket if I had remained in the public service a year or two."
Mark Twain, Roughing It
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Humor
Wednesday, August 19, 2009
Free to Choose
In 1980, the United States was mired in a deep recession. Unemployment would eventually hit 10%. Interest rates would rise to the high teens. The United States appeared exhausted and helpless. The Soviet Union bristled with nuclear weapons and imperial ambition. The Japanese appeared economically ascendant.
1980 was also the year that Milton and Rose Friedman broadcast the first episode of the PBS series Free to Choose: A Personal Statement. Those broadcasts played an important role in the popular revival of free market ideas.
Now the entire series is available via IdeaChannel.tv.
At a time when we are wrestling with our own economic demons, it may be useful to revisit some old friends.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
8:34 AM
1 comments
Labels: Social Theory
Tuesday, August 18, 2009
Protest Capitalism! Spend Money!
Demonstrating either a matchless entrepreneurial instinct or a hopelessly muddled morality, a Dutch designer is promoting the post-capitalist society by selling expensive T-shirts.
Twan Verdonck launched a new fashion project he calls "We Are Numbers." It consists of selling designer T-shirts for the price of 25 euros each (about US $37). He says his T-shirt project is about consumerism, identity, and fashion. The ultimate goal of the project is "universal love, low consumption and unlimited creativity."
Tactfully, he did not mention his personal goal of earning a comfortable living from satisfying the kind people who believe that they can contribute to universal love, low consumption, and unlimited creativity by buying a T-shirt.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Business
Monday, August 17, 2009
Public Instability
"The internal effects of a mutable policy are still more calamitous. It poisons the blessing of liberty itself. It will be of little avail to the people, that the laws are made by men of their own choice, if the laws be so voluminous that they cannot be read, or so incoherent that they cannot be understood; if they be repealed or revised before they are promulgated, or undergo such incessant changes that no man, who knows what the law is to-day, can guess what it will be to-morrow. Law is defined to be a rule of action; but how can that be a rule, which is little known, and less fixed?
Another effect of public instability is the unreasonable advantage it gives to the sagacious, the enterprising, and the moneyed few over the industrious and uniformed mass of the people. Every new regulation concerning commerce or revenue, or in any way affecting the value of the different species of property, presents a new harvest to those who watch the change, and can trace its consequences; a harvest, reared not by themselves, but by the toils and cares of the great body of their fellow-citizens. This is a state of things in which it may be said with some truth that laws are made for the few, not for the many."
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Social Theory
Sunday, August 16, 2009
Rationing Health Care
"Virtually all nationalized health systems, neither nourished nor updated by profit-driven private investment, eventually lead to rationing."
Camille Paglia, in Salon.com
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Health Care
Saturday, August 15, 2009
Hayek on Bastiat
The great free market intellectual Friedrich Hayek (1899 - 1992) wrote the following introduction to an edition of Bastiat's selected essays:
"Even those who may question the eminence of Frédéric Bastiat as an economic theorist will grant that he was a publicist of genius. Joseph Schumpeter calls him "the most brilliant economic journalist who ever lived." For the purpose of introducing the present volume, which contains some of the most successful of his writings for the general public, we might well leave it at that. One might even grant Schumpeter's harsh assessment of Bastiat that "he was not a theorist" without seriously diminishing his stature. It is true that when, at the end of his extremely short career as a writer, he attempted to provide a theoretical justification for his general conceptions, he did not satisfy the professionals. It would indeed have been a miracle if a man who, after only five years as a regular writer on public affairs, attempted in a few months, and with a mortal illness rapidly closing in on him, to defend the points on which he differed from established doctrine, had fully succeeded in this too. Yet one may ask whether it was not only his early death at the age of forty-nine that prevented him. His polemical writings, which in consequence are the most important ones he has left, certainly prove that he had an insight into what was significant and a gift for going to the heart of the matter that would have provided him with ample material for real contributions to science.
Nothing illustrates this better than the celebrated title of the first essay in the present volume. "What is seen and what is not seen in political economy!" No one has ever stated more clearly in a single phrase the central difficulty of a rational economic policy and, I would like to add, the decisive argument for economic freedom. It is the idea compressed into these few words that made me use the word "genius" in the opening sentence. It is indeed a text around which one might expound a whole system of libertarian economic policy. And though it constitutes the title for only the first essay in this volume, it provides the leading idea for all. Bastiat illustrates its meaning over and over again in refuting the current fallacies of his time. I shall later indicate that, though the views he combats are today usually advanced only in a more sophisticated guise, they have basically not changed very much since Bastiat's time. But first I want to say a few words about the more general significance of his central idea.
This is simply that if we judge measures of economic policy solely by their immediate and concretely foreseeable effects, we shall not only not achieve a viable order but shall be certain progressively to extinguish freedom and thereby prevent more good than our measures will produce. Freedom is important in order that all the different individuals can make full use of the particular circumstances of which only they know. We therefore never know what beneficial actions we prevent if we restrict their freedom to serve their fellows in whatever manner they wish. All acts of interference, however, amount to such restrictions. They are, of course, always undertaken to achieve some definite objective. Against the foreseen direct results of such actions of government we shall in each individual case be able to balance only the mere probability that some unknown but beneficial actions by some individuals will be prevented. In consequence, if such decisions are made from case to case and not governed by an attachment to freedom as a general principle, freedom is bound to lose in almost every case. Bastiat was indeed right in treating freedom of choice as a moral principle that must never be sacrificed to considerations of expediency; because there is perhaps no aspect of freedom that would not be abolished if it were to be respected only where the concrete damage caused by its abolition can be pointed out.
Bastiat directed his arguments against certain ever recurring fallacies as they were employed in his time. Few people would employ them today quite as naively as it was still possible to do then. But let the reader not deceive himself that these same fallacies no longer play an important role in contemporary economic discussion: they are today expressed merely in a more sophisticated form and are therefore more difficult to detect. The reader who has learnt to recognize these stock fallacies in their simpler manifestations will at least be on his guard when he finds the same conclusions derived from what appears to be a more scientific argument. It is characteristic of much of recent economics that by ever new arguments it has tried to vindicate those very prejudices which are so attractive because the maxims that follow from them are so pleasant or convenient: spending is a good thing, and saving is bad; waste benefits and economy harms the mass of the people; money will do more good in the hands of the government than in those of the people; it is the duty of government to see that everybody gets what he deserves; etc., etc.
None of these ideas has lost any of its power in our time. The only difference is that Bastiat, in combatting them, was on the whole fighting on the side of the professional economists against popular beliefs exploited by interested parties, while similar proposals are today propagated by an influential school of economists in a most impressive and, to the layman, largely unintelligible garb. It is doubtful whether there is one among the fallacies which one might have hoped Bastiat had killed once and for all that has not experienced its resurrection. I shall give only one example. To an account of Bastiat's best-known economic fable, The Petition of the Candlemakers against the Competition of the Sun (contained in a companion volume to this), in which it is demanded that windows should be prohibited because of the benefit which the prosperity of the candlemakers would confer on everyone else, a well-known French textbook of the history of economics adds in its latest edition the following footnote: "It should be noted that according to Keynes—on the assumption of underemployment and in accordance with the theory of the multiplier—this argument of the candlemakers is literally and fully valid.
The attentive reader will notice that, while Bastiat grapples with so many economic panaceas which are familiar to us, one of the main dangers of our time does not appear in his pages. Though he has to deal with various queer proposals for using credit which were current in his time, straight inflation through a government deficit seemed in his age not a major danger. An increase of expenditure means for him necessarily and immediately an increase in taxation. The reason is that, as among all people who have gone through a major inflation within living memory, a continuous depreciation of money was not a thing with which people would have put up with in his day. So if the reader should be inclined to feel superior to the rather simple fallacies that Bastiat often finds it necessary to refute, he should remember that in some other respects his compatriots of more than a hundred years ago were considerably wiser than our generation."
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Bastiat
Friday, August 14, 2009
What's Wrong With Business Education
Professor Henry Mintzberg is a long-time critic of business schools, even though (or perhaps because) he graduated from one and is employed by another.
In this dialogue with businessman Ricardo Semler, Professor Mintzberg drops one gem after another, such as:
"Canada is one country that works remarkably well in practice, but doesn't work at all in theory."
"You can't create a manager in a classroom. If you try, you create hubris."
"Management is where art and craft and science meet. You can't do anything with craft when people have no experience, 'cause craft by definition is rooted in experience. And art tends to get treated in the classroom in a kind of voyeuristic way, we have cases about entrepreneurs and things...so the emphasis is really on the science or the analytical side and I think that distorts things. I wouldn't close down the MBA programs...I would simply recognize them for what they are: training in analytical skills for analytical jobs...just don't pretend we're creating them as managers...Don't close them down but recognize them for what they are."
"You shouldn't be a manager because you got an MBA. You should earn your managerial stripes."
"Regular MBA programs train the wrong people in the wrong ways with the wrong consequences."
Semler gets a good line in, too, when he says that most business schools bring in business people like zoo animals, and have a sign outside the classroom that says "Don't feed the businessman."
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
1 comments
Thursday, August 13, 2009
Vodoo Economics
Over at Organizations and Markets, economist Peter Klein reminds us of the subject of the boring lecture in the late, great John Hughes classic, Ferris Bueller's Day Off.
Reading the script is almost as funny as hearing Ben Stein act it out.
"In 1930, the Republican-controlled House of Representatives, in an effort to alleviate the effects of the... Anyone? Anyone?... the Great Depression, passed the... Anyone? Anyone? The tariff bill? The Hawley-Smoot Tariff Act? Which, anyone? Raised or lowered?... raised tariffs, in an effort to collect more revenue for the federal government. Did it work? Anyone? Anyone know the effects? It did not work, and the United States sank deeper into the Great Depression. Today we have a similar debate over this. Anyone know what this is? Class? Anyone? Anyone? Anyone seen this before? The Laffer Curve. Anyone know what this says? It says that at this point on the revenue curve, you will get exactly the same amount of revenue as at this point. This is very controversial. Does anyone know what Vice President Bush called this in 1980? Anyone? Something-d-o-o economics. "Voodoo" economics."
Ferris Bueller's Day Off came out in 1986. Do you think it did to the economics profession what Sideways did for merlot?
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Humor
Wednesday, August 12, 2009
The Quotable Bastiat
Si l'on trouvait en France une mine d'or, il ne s'ensuit pas que nous eussions intérêt à l'exploiter. Il est même certain que l'entreprise devrait être négligée, si chaque once d'or absorbait plus de notre travail qu'une once d'or achetée au Mexique avec du drap. En ce cas, il vaudrait mieux continuer à voir nos mines dans nos métiers. — Ce qui est vrai de l'or l'est du fer.
"If someone found a gold mine in France, it does not follow that it would be to our interest to work it. In fact, it is certain that the enterprise should not be undertaken if each ounce of gold absorbed more of our labor than would an ounce of gold bought from Mexico with cloth. In that case it would be better to continue to regard our looms as gold mines. And what is true of gold is no less true of iron."
Chapitre XVII de la seconde série des Sophismes Économiques/Economic Sophisms, II.17.11
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
2
comments
Labels: Bastiat
Tuesday, August 11, 2009
Thoughts on Business
Business schools don't teach business. They teach technocratic social science and produce the kind of people who still believe in five year plans.
A business plan is just a hunch dressed up to make a good first impression.
A business plan is a prim analysis of what will work. Business is the messy search for what actually does.
A profitable business, honestly run, is one of mankind's greatest achievements. It is also one of his least appreciated.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Business
Monday, August 10, 2009
The New Wall Street
Investor Wilbur Ross comments on what I call the last boom town in America: Washington, DC.
"Washington is becoming the new Wall Street...The $64 question is will government be able to re-exit from that, and yet leave the economy intact, or are we moving toward a permanent socialization of the capital markets?"
From NPR.
The better question is, why human nature should operate any differently in Washington than it does in New York?
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Politics
Sunday, August 9, 2009
Clunkers, Winners, and Losers
The "cash for clunkers" program is popular, but that's because we are only celebrating the program's winners.
There are losers, too. Lots of them. Nothing in Washington happens without somebody losing something.
To paraphrase the old truth about poker, take a look around Washington and spot the sucker. If you can't, you're it.
Here's how the program really works:
Winners:
Auto rental companies
Automakers
Auto dealers
New auto buyers
Scrap metal dealers
Politicians
Losers:
Automobile mechanics
Tire stores
Automobile parts dealers
Taxpayers
Low-end used car buyers
In the final analysis, it is not clear that the benefit to the winners is greater than the cost to the losers. In fact, what has probably happened is a zero-sum transfer of money from one group to another.
Moving money around creates a lot of excitement, especially for the receiver. But this kind of excitement is not prosperity. It is the illusion of prosperity, creating a Potemkin village in a land left poorer for the effort.
Rather than create the appearance of prosperity by rushing money around from one place to another by decree, we should rely on the boring but effective policy of simply leaving money in the hands of those who made it in the first place. Let them decide where to spend it.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
2
comments
Labels: Politics
Saturday, August 8, 2009
Utopia or Freedom
Thomas Sowell on chronic human discontent:
"The universe was not made to our specifications. Nor were human beings. So there is nothing surprising in the fact that we are dissatisfied with many things at many times. The big question is whether we are prepared to follow any politician who claims to be able to “solve” our “problem.”
If we are, then there will be a never ending series of “solutions,” each causing new problems calling for still more “solutions.” That way lies a never-ending quest, costing ever increasing amounts of taxpayers money and — more important — ever greater losses of your freedom to live your own life as you see fit, rather than as presumptuous elites dictate.
Ultimately, our choice is to give up Utopian quests or give up our freedom."
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Social Theory
Friday, August 7, 2009
The Failings of Capitalism

"...moaning and groaning about the failings of capitalism are really part of political theatre in a recession. In my youth, the Communist Party would meet delightedly during every recession and proclaim that capitalism was now in its final death throes. Even after the collapse of communism, dirges are still sung by other parties. The singing ends abruptly as economies pick up again, and turns out to be more a recession ritual than an anthem for reform."
Swaminathan S Anklesaria Aiyar, consulting editor of The Economic Times (India)
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Social Theory
Thursday, August 6, 2009
When is Big Too Big?
We all know government is big. But when is big too big?
A new study by the
Institute for Market Economics (IME) in Bulgaria concludes the government sector should be no larger than 20% to 30% of the national economy.
The average government sector for the OECD countries now exceeds 41% of GDP.
The results of the study indicate that trying to stimulate the economy by expanding government probably won't work.
The study was sponsored by the non-partisan Center for Freedom and Prosperity Foundation in the United States and the European Coalition for Economic Growth based in Vienna, Austria.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Social Theory
Wednesday, August 5, 2009
World's Oldest Proof
Strained logic appears over and over again in human discourse, especially when passion overwhelms the requirement for proof.
Or, better yet, when passion becomes the proof. This is the flaw in Life, Inc., the book that I reviewed on this site yesterday.
Consider the following additional examples of passionate but faulty logic, culled from history:
Adolf Hitler:
I don't like Jews.
People behave badly.
A lot of people are Jews.
Therefore, Jews make people behave badly.
Islamic Extremist:
I don't like Americans.
People behave badly.
A lot of people envy Americans.
Therefore, Americans are the reason people behave badly.
Naomi Klein:
I don't like Milton Friedman.
People behave badly.
A lot of people read Milton Friedman.
Therefore, Milton Friedman makes people behave badly.
Richard Dawkins, scientist and militant atheist:
I don't like religion.
People behave badly.
People are religious.
Therefore, religion makes people behave badly.
Ben Stein, star of the anti-evolution movie, Expelled
I don't like evolution.
People behave badly.
People are taught evolution.
Therefore, evolution makes people behave badly.
Gun Control Advocates:
I don't like guns.
People behave badly.
People own guns.
Therefore, guns make people behave badly.
PETA, People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals
I don't like meat.
People behave badly.
People eat meat.
Therefore, meat makes people behave badly.
The variations are endless. Perhaps the world's oldest and weakest proof begins with "I don't like..."
On the other hand, it is apparently a very effective way to demonize a race, a nation, a man, a product, or an idea.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Social Theory
Tuesday, August 4, 2009
Carrots and Corporations
Life, Inc. is a book that might have been great. It deals with an important topic, the role of the corporation in society, and there are moments when it hits the mark, such as:
"The current situation resembles the managed capitalism of Mussolini's Italy, in particular. It shares a common intellectual heritage (in disappointed progressives who wanted to order society on a scientific understanding of human nature), the same political alliance (the collaboration of the state and the corporate sector), and some of the same techniques for securing consent (through public relations and propaganda). Above all, it shares with fascism the same deep suspicion of free humans."
But the author cannot free himself from his self-described "hip, overgentrified, Brooklynite" world view. He drops complaints about "the toxically wealthy." He doesn't like mini malls or superstores. He complains about "hermetically sealed food courts." He wants to dismantle society and replace it with something more livable and sustainable.
In the end, his argument boils down to this:
I don't like corporations.
People behave badly.
People use a lot of corporate stuff.
Therefore, corporations are the reason people behave badly.
Of course, this makes as much sense as saying
I don't like carrots.
People behave badly.
People eat a lot of carrots.
Therefore, carrots are the reason people behave badly.
Corporations, like individuals, deserve criticism and punishment when they lie, cheat, steal, or resort to violence. But it is a metaphysical stretch -- dare I call it a lie? -- to say that the very nature of the corporation is immoral.
No doubt, it is easier to denounce corporations as inherently corrupt rather than to directly confront the common thesis in all such arguments: People behave badly. But we might as well blame that unpleasant fact on carrots.
People behaved badly long before corporations existed. Carrots have been around a lot longer. Therefore it must be true that carrots are more likely to cause bad behavior than corporations.
Note: Here is an earlier post on Life, Inc.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Social Theory
Monday, August 3, 2009
No Choice is No Fun
Forbes magazine just published an article on the funniest US television commercials. The top spot went to an IKEA commercial about a lamp.
My personal favorite, the Wendy's Soviet fashion show, was number 19 on the list. It not only sells hamburgers, it makes comparative economic analysis funny.
Remember, "Having no choice is no fun."
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
8:08 AM
0
comments
Labels: Humor
Sunday, August 2, 2009
The High Priests of Job Creation
Across the land the cry was heard, "Give us more jobs!"
And Lo, many jobs were given, but little work was done.
Of course these lines do not appear in any sacred text. At least none yet. But when the job-creation epic of our time is finally set to paper, they surely will, in one form or another.
You are reading a short meditation on the growing metaphysical distinction between doing "work" and having a "job." And metaphysical is not too strong a word here. The meanings of these words are separating as surely as day from night or land from water.
Once, they meant roughly the same thing. "Job" entered the English language around the 16th century with the meaning "a piece of work," as distinguished from continuous labor. The first use in the sense of "work for pay" was in the 17th century. Over the next three centuries, the two words became interchangeable. Until now.
Now, a job is something you do for somebody else. Employees have jobs. Owners and housewives have work.
Now, politicians throw the word "job" around like it is a talisman that can produce wondrous effects and will justify any sacrifice. Politicians have become the high priests of job creation, but they rarely stop to ask if the job they invoke is valuable or necessary. You will hear about green jobs, high-paying jobs, jobs of the future, and good jobs, but you won't hear about valuable or necessary work.
Even when politicians talk about putting people back to work, they don't mean the kind of work done by small businesses or the self-employed. They are talking about corporate jobs, the kind they can recruit with tax incentives and great fanfare; the kind of jobs they can count, not the work done by plumbers, electricians, shopkeepers, bar tenders, auto mechanics and the like.
The news media aids the politicians in promoting this new faith in jobs. It tracks the job count like augurs used to count the geese in the sky of ancient Rome: 7 jobs here, 15 jobs there, 1,000 jobs somewhere else. Jobs, like victories, are won or lost. Jobs are omens, portents of our future. More are a sign that the sacrifices are working, less a sure sign that we must sacrifice even more.
Somewhere, in the enthusiasm about jobs, we have lost our concern about work. "We pretend to work and they pretend to pay us," was the jest about jobs in the old USSR. Has it found new life on the job in the USA?
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Business
Saturday, August 1, 2009
Business and Biology
What are the connections between business and biology? Economic progress depends on the hybridization of ideas, or as Matt Ridley likes to put it, "Ideas having sex."
Author Ridley is a rare find: smart, funny, easy to understand, and though-provoking. In short, he's everything you'd hope for in an intellectual. Even better, he understands markets.
His background includes science, journalism, and business. Ridley studied zoology at Oxford. In 1993, he began a career in journalism with the Economist, first as the science reporter, then as its Washington correspondent, and finally as the magazine's American editor.
In this video, he discusses the connections between his prior work his upcoming book on economics.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Social Theory
Friday, July 31, 2009
The Quotable Bastiat
Supposez, si cela vous amuse, que l'étranger nous inonde de toutes sortes de marchandises utiles, sans nous rien demander; que nos importations sont infinies et nos exportations nulles, je vous défie de me prouver que nous en serons plus pauvres.
"Suppose, if that amuses you, that the foreigner inundates us with all sorts of useful goods, asking nothing in return; that our imports are infinite and our exports, nil; I defy you to prove to me that we should be poorer on that account."
Chapitre VI Sophismes Économiques/Chapter 6, Economic Sophisms
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
3:12 PM
0
comments
Labels: Bastiat, Free trade
Thursday, July 30, 2009
Free Download: "Mind of the Market"
Michael Shermer's book, Mind of the Market, is a thought-provoking look at economics from an evolutionary point of view.
He challenges conservatives and liberals alike to consider evolution as the fundamental process of both the natural world and the world economy.
For the next week or so, you can download a free MP3 of a chapter of Mind of the Market.
I've discussed Shermer's work in previous posts, referenced here.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Social Theory
Wednesday, July 29, 2009
Laugh, Don't Cry!

Just because creating wealth is morally and materially important doesn't mean that business can't laugh at itself.
Despair, Inc. is a business that makes fun of business. It makes parodies of those motivational posters found in offices large and small.
Some examples:
MEETINGS: None of us is as dumb as all of us.
BLAME: The secret to success is knowing who to blame for your failures.
DREAMS: Dreams are like rainbows. Only idiots chase them.
These posters look great in government offices, too, as the line between business and government gets blurrier. And this tee shirt says it all:
GOVERNMENT: If you think the problems we create are bad, just wait until you see our solutions.
Despair, Inc. joins a select group of humor links in the lower left hand corner of the Bastiat Society's home page. Laugh, don't cry!
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Humor
Tuesday, July 28, 2009
Is the Federal Reserve Broken?
George Selgin, of the University of Georgia, has been described as "a scholar's scholar."
In this video, he participates in a panel discussion of the topic, "Is the Federal Reserve System Broken?" The event is sponsored by the Smith Family Foundation.
Other participants include Stephen Axilrod, a former member of the Federal Reserve Board of Governors; Sharyn O'Halloran of Columbia University; and Peter Schiff of Euro-Pacific Capital.
Get full screen video and the embed code here.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
8:04 AM
0
comments
Labels: Politics
Monday, July 27, 2009
Signs of Progress
From Berlin, some encouraging signs of humanity's progress.
Not so long ago, the radical German Left used to labor day and night to justify the Berlin Wall (under construction in the photo), the guard towers, the fences, and the shoot-to-kill orders of the East German worker's paradise.
Now it is reduced to just complaining about the trains.
According to the Financial Times, the radical Left is blaming capitalism for the shutdown of the Berliner S-Bahn commuter railway. Last week, the company that runs the railway withdrew about two-thirds of its cars from service, after a derailment and safety checks showed about 4,000 wheels needed to be replaced.
Ulrich Maurer, the party's chief whip, complained, "The chaos in the Berliner S-Bahn is a lesson in the consequences of capitalism. It is a graphic depiction of where subservience to financial markets' greedy pursuit of profit ultimately leads."
Regretfully, Comrade Maurer missed a superb opportunity to trot out that old chestnut of authoritarian self-justification, "We caused death and suffering when we ran the country, but at least the trains ran on time."
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:14 AM
0
comments
Labels: Social Theory
Sunday, July 26, 2009
An Optimist's Creed
Here is what you might call an Optimist's Creed, from Steven Horwitz, an economics professor at St. Lawrence University:
"If one thinks about all the bad economic policies and the general growth of the state that has taken place since the early 70s, the fact that life is still so much better in so many ways should lead one to think ... that the Smithian forces of the division of labor and the power of Schumpeterian innovation will indeed continue to conquer the stupidity of the state. No doubt the fight will be a tougher one in the years to come, thanks to the events of the last year, but both history and theory suggest that the combined efforts of humanity coordinated by even restricted markets will still win out over the stumbling and bumbling of the political class."
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
1:00 PM
0
comments
Labels: Social Theory
Saturday, July 25, 2009
Miracles, Public and Private
Even as things get better, we find plenty to complain about. Our burden is a happiness that cannot last.
Chronic human discontent encourages a stream of extravagant promises, one miracle cure after another. Sometimes, these promises are small: know the future, find true love, lose weight, grow hair, or get rich quick.
Sometimes, these promises are big; end income inequality, manage climate change, provide quality health care for everyone, or put every child through college.
In principle, big miracle programs are no different than the little miracle products sold in infomercials. Both appeal to our chronic discontent. We are told "This way lies happiness."
The difference is in who pays and for how long. Private miracles are individual expenses and private disappointments. It's easy to deal with that kind of disappointment; just don't buy that promise again.
But everybody pays for the promise of public miracles, and there's no easy way to get out of the deal when it fails to deliver happiness or it costs more than you expected.
We are constantly reminded that we should be wary of miracle products, and rightly so. But we should be doubly wary of miracle programs. If it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Education
Friday, July 24, 2009
Words Without a Language
Trying to control the price of health care without a market is like trying control the definition of words without a language.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:11 AM
0
comments
Labels: Health Care
Thursday, July 23, 2009
The Great Recession of 2008 - 2009
Prof. Steve Horwitz puts the current recession into historical perspective and explores the different approaches to recovery. Taped at Evenings at FEE on July 18, 2009 in Irvington, NY.
A few highlights:
* To say that greed caused the housing bubble is like saying that gravity causes plane crashes.
* Interest rates are not the price of money. They are the price of time.
* Printing more money to get out of a recession is like drinking more to avoid a hangover.
* Why did so many financial institutions loan money to people who could not pay it back? FNMA and Freddie had a Congressional requiring that 52% of their financing would be with borrowers with income below the median household income.
* Everybody wants more affordable housing, until they discover what that really means.
* The three major rating services operate as a government-maintained cartel. They don't have any competition, therefore they don't learn.
* Alan Greenspan encouraged financially risky behavior by lowering interest rates when markets misbehaved.
* The recession is the recovery.
* The Obama administration sees every problem in terms of health care, the environment, and education.
Watch the whole presentation here.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Social Theory
Wednesday, July 22, 2009
Nearly Everything is Made Nearly Everywhere
Another fabulous job by the folks at reason.tv. Bikinis and Boudreaux, a winning combination.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
1 comments
Labels: Free trade
Tuesday, July 21, 2009
Who was Frédéric Bastiat?
From Cercle Frédéric Bastiat:
Frédéric Bastiat was born in Bayonne in 1801, and died in Rome in 1850. But his family was from a little town called Mugron, where he spent most of his life, and where he has a statue.
Mugron is located to the North-East of Bayonne, in a French Department called "Les Landes". He spent the better part of his last years in Paris, as the editor of Le Journal des Economistes, and from 1848, as a member of Parliament.
As an economist, gifted with a very clear mind and a devastating sense of humor, he renewed the Economic science of his time by developing it from the standpoint of the consumer, i.e. the people. He was the tireless apostle of freedom of exchange and freedom of choice by individuals, without constraints or subsidies. His works are as fresh and relevant today as they were 150 years ago, and his numerous predictions about the evolution of Institutions and Societies have invariably come true.
As a philosopher, he was the precursor of many present day Libertarians, building normative ethics on the foundations of individual liberty and responsibility.
As a local judge, he was a paragon of efficiency and equity.
As a politician with a great foresight, he was an advocate of minimum government, and fought against the indefinite extension of public expenditure. He criticized colonial expeditions and slavery. He argued for the separation of powers, for preventing MPs from being ministers at the same time, and for limiting the number of civil servants in the Assembly. He was for a greater participation of women in politics.
His major writings are "The Law," "Economic Sophisms," "What Is Seen And What Is Not Seen," "Economic Harmonies". They have been translated into many languages.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Bastiat
Monday, July 20, 2009
Business as Usual
"Art is business, business art, -- that is all
Ye know on earth, and all ye need to know."
With apologies to John Keats, the lines above express what everyone in Hollywood privately knows but cannot publicly confess: For all of its posturing, Hollywood is not about art; it's not about meaning; it's not about beauty, and it's certainly not about truth. Hollywood is about business, with more contracts and bottom lines than you'll find in the board room at Wal-Mart.
Hollywood produces a product, movies, like McDonald's produces fast food. That's not a bad thing, at least not until Hollywood tries to get away with an ethical double standard.
Most movies portray business as inseparable from the sins of deception, intimidation, ridicule, mockery, and exploitation. Think bad guy = businessman.
Of course, this is a preposterous mischaracterization of business. According to Thomas Stanley, the best-selling author of The Millionaire Next Door, the average millionaire in the United States owns a small business, not a large corporation; he is married to his first and only wife; he drives a modest car, often a pick-up truck; he shops at Wal-Mart; and he lives in a nice house, but not a mansion. In other words, the average American millionaire is a pretty nice guy, the kind who pays his taxes, mows his lawn, values his customers and his employees, helps his friends, and takes care of his family. Hardly the stuff of villainy.
So where does the evil business caricature come from? Maybe Hollywood mistakes the way it does business for the way everyone else behaves. A guilty man sees the evidence of his crime everywhere.
Consider the legal storm surrounding the hit movie Bruno. Forbes reports,"To nab...unsuspecting interviews, Baron Cohen's production company had reportedly set up four "shell companies" with LA addresses and phone numbers, including Amesbury Chase, Chromium Films, Cold Stream Productions and Coral Blue Productions. Fake Web sites with bogus logos were created for all four of these shell companies, but they have since been taken down."
Shell companies, air-tight contracts, deceptive promises, and large profits. It all sounds like the plot of a John Grisham thriller. But it's just business as usual in Hollywood.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Business
Sunday, July 19, 2009
Educating Drivers Everyday
Educating your fellow citizens about important figures in the history of freedom can be as simple as driving around town with a custom license plate.
Have you seen others?
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Bastiat Society
Saturday, July 18, 2009
Universal Car Care
The Galen Institute of Alexandria, VA describes itself as "a non-profit research organization devoted exclusively to health policy. We work to promote a more informed public debate over ideas that advance individual freedom, consumer choice, and competition in the health sector."
This video won first place in the Institute's "Do No Harm" video contest. View the other winners here.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
6:55 AM
0
comments
Labels: Health Care, Humor
Friday, July 17, 2009
A False and Dangerous Conclusion
"Too many people, especially in Europe, equate mistakes made by economists with a failure of economic liberalism. Their logic seems to be that if economists got things wrong, then politicians will do better. That is a false—and dangerous—conclusion."
Economist.com, "What Went Wrong With Economics"
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Social Theory
Thursday, July 16, 2009
Life, Inc.
It's hard to tell who's the comedian here, Rushkoff or Colbert. Both are over-the-top stereotypes. One of them isn't acting.
Douglas Rushkoff, author of the book Life, Inc., thinks corporations run the world and treat "the planet itself as a bunch of regions to be exploited and conquered rather than to be taken care of." This statement is absurd. If he wasn't so earnest, he'd be funnier than Colbert.
Rushkoff conflates government and corporations. This is a common mistake, especially among those people who want to believe in the goodness of government, but who don't want to trust business. To put it bluntly, these people are blaming the victim for the crime.
Government, not corporations, has always led the way in exploiting and conquering. In those cases where business got involved, it acted as an agent for government, often as a government-mandated monopoly. Such is the case of the early trading companies Rushkoff mentions in this interview.
No Mr. Rushkoff, corporations don't rule the world, but that ambition lurks in the breast of every politician where it is far more dangerous to the human race than any business expansion plan at Starbucks or Wal-mart. For, as H. L. Mencken said, "A good politician is as quite unthinkable as an honest burglar."
| The Colbert Report | Mon - Thurs 11:30pm / 10:30c | |||
| Douglas Rushkoff | ||||
| www.colbertnation.com | ||||
| ||||
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
8:29 AM
0
comments
Labels: Humor
Join the Bastiat Society!
What are you waiting for?
* Join the movement to promote the moral and material benefits of free enterprise.
* Start a Bastiat Society monthly meeting in your home town. We'll tell you how.
* Get regular updates on what's happening and what's new.
* Annual membership is $200
* Founding membership is $2,000
* Our monthly meetings are free and open to the public through the generosity of our members and founding members
Register here:
Donate here:
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
8:07 AM
0
comments
Labels: Bastiat Society
Infallible Gods and the Humans Who Worship Them
Today's progressives are the intellectual heirs of the socialists of the last century and a half. They are the harshest critics of business, and they are among the most eager to use the power of the state.
Like their forefathers, they have no patience with anyone who displays the slightest doubt that the problems of society can be solved by smart people using vast political power for the greater good. As Dostoevsky said of the socialists of his day in late 19th century Russia, "they believe that a social system that has come out of some mathematical brain is going to organize all humanity at once and make it just and sinless in an instant, quicker than any living process!"
This perennial article of progressive faith requires a willful ignorance of two uncomfortable facts. We might even call them inconvenient truths:
1. No group of individuals is smart enough to run the complex and constantly shifting affairs of an entire nation. The hubris to claim such knowledge is a hallmark of our species; the actual possession of such knowledge is not. Like the ancient shaman who claimed a special knowledge of the supernatural, today's progressive claims a special knowledge of the super state.
2. Humans have a stubborn tendency to pursue their own self-interest. It's not that humans are always opposed to the greater good. It's just that self-interest is a more reliable bet.
The reality of human nature -- always bound by ignorance and regularly motivated by self-interest -- makes it unwise to hand anyone too much power, no matter what they promise to do with it. Like the ring in Tolkien's trilogy, power corrupts all those who use it, even when they begin with pure hearts and a noble purpose.
Socialism is a system fit only for infallible gods and the humans who worship them.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Social Theory
Wednesday, July 15, 2009
Cap and Trade = Tax and Control
.jpg)
""Cap and trade" is first a massive indirect tax on the American people and hence another source of revenue for Congress. More importantly "cap and trade" is just about the most effective tool for controlling most economic activity short of openly declaring ourselves a communist nation and it's a radical environmentalist's dream come true."
Economist Walter E. Williams.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
6:50 AM
0
comments
Labels: Environmentalism
Tuesday, July 14, 2009
Elmer Fudd Explains Capitalism
Entertainment both shapes and is shaped by culture. All too often these days, popular entertainment portrays business as unqualified evil. But that has not always been the case. In this short cartoon from the 1950s, Elmer Fudd does a remarkably good job explaining the individual and social benefits of capitalism.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
1 comments
Labels: Humor
Monday, July 13, 2009
Capitalism Works
Capitalism works. If not here, then somewhere. It springs from human nature, and capitalism is so necessary to human well-being that when it is suppressed in one place, it will appear in another.
That is the lesson to read in the following little bit of news: "Fortune magazine recently reported that the number of U.S. companies in the world’s top 500 fell to the lowest level ever, while more Chinese firms than ever made the list. Thirty-seven Chinese companies now rank in the top 500, including nine new entries. Meanwhile, the number of U.S. firms has fallen to 140, the lowest total since Fortune began the list in 1995."
From National Review Online, "The Road to Economic Demoralization," by Larry Kudlow
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Social Theory
Sunday, July 12, 2009
The Quotable Bastiat

"If two workers wish to combine their strengths in order to share the product in accordance with agreed proportions, or exchange their products with each other, or if one wishes to make the other a loan or a gift, what does the law have to do with this? Nothing, I think, other than require the fulfilling of agreements and prevent or punish misrepresentation, violence or fraud."
From the Frédéric Bastiat Circle.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Bastiat
Saturday, July 11, 2009
No Magic Road
In "Making Work, Destroying Wealth," David Boaz of the Cato Institute writes:
"President-elect Obama proposes that the federal government “create or save” jobs by spending upwards of $600 billion. Where would this money come from? If it comes from taxes, it will be taken out of the more efficient private sector to be spent in the less efficient government sector, and the higher tax rates will discourage work and investment. If it is borrowed, it will again simply be transferred from market allocation to political allocation, and our debt burden will grow even greater. And if the money is simply created out of thin air on the balance sheets of the Federal Reserve, then it will surely lead to inflation.
There is no magic road to wealth. You have to work, save, and invest. And when the government lures individuals and businesses into making bad investments with cheap money, the malinvestment has to be liquidated. Avoiding that truth, prolonging the process of adjustment, is a good way to turn a recession into a depression. And you can’t get economic growth back by breaking windows...or spending money you don’t have."
Boaz cites Bastiat's famous work, "That Which is Seen, and that Which is Not Seen."
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:09 AM
0
comments
Labels: Wealth
Friday, July 10, 2009
Early Warning: Michael Moore at Work
Entertainment Weekly reports that Michael Moore says his new movie is to be titled Capitalism: A Love Story. The film will focus on "the disastrous impact that corporate dominance and out-of-control profit motives have on the lives of Americans and citizens of the world" and will be released on October 2nd.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Business
Thursday, July 9, 2009
United Breaks Guitars
Traveling by air lost its romance years ago. Instead of a consumer experience, flying is an ordeal we endure.
But not every consumer suffers in silence. Some create art out of their suffering.
From BusinessWeek Management IQ.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Humor
Tuesday, July 7, 2009
A National Straitjacket
T.Boone Pickens was recently on CNBC calling for a national energy plan. Without such a plan, he says that in ten years the United States will be importing 75% of its energy, and that oil will be $300 a barrel.
Such precision in long range forecasting is admirable, but it is not credible.
We've heard this kind of thing before. Remember Uncle Joe's Five Year Plans? Or the Great Helmsman's Great Leap Forward? Now we have the paradox of an American businessman promoting the same kind of national-scale economic planning that worked so well in the USSR and Mao's Red China.
With friends like this, who needs enemies?
There is no reason to believe that T. Boone Pickens is any better at telling the future than the rest of us. Ten years ago, the number one planning issue was Y2K. It turned out to be a non-event.
In 1999, the most important things to come were apparently unimaginable, even to a visionary like Mr. Pickens: a major terrorist attack in New York, the near death of the American airline industry, a war in Afghanistan, another war in Iraq, record low interest rates, the drowning of New Orleans, a housing bubble, a stock market bubble, the worst recession since the Great Depression, a government takeover of GM, Wachovia at 76 cents per share, two bankrupt Wall Street firms, and a government rescue and significant ownership of Citigroup.
Alas, the world we live in is so messy and filled with so many surprises that it makes any national ten year plan a joke. Such a plan leaves no room for individual preferences or the discovery of new knowledge. Inevitably, such a plan turns into a national straitjacket.
If Mr. Pickens really wants to help the nation, he should promote the kind of planning that made him a success in business. That kind of planning is individual and opportunistic, not national and proscriptive. Long-term results emerge from individuals responding to rapidly changing opportunities, not from one individual commandeering an entire industry.
Mr. Pickens has demonstrated the ability to make opportunistic business decisions, and for that he should be admired. But success in business does not qualify him or anyone else to engineer a master plan for America's Great Leap Forward. Believing in such a plan is a mistake; following it would be an even bigger one.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
8:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Energy
Monday, July 6, 2009
Driving Like Crazy
In this interview with reason.tv, author P. J. O'Rourke talks about his new book, Driving Like Crazy, and the once-great American automobile business.
A few choice moments:
"The automobile is the source of no bad stuff in America."
"There's something romantic about the train, but try getting the tracks to come to your house."
"Politics is the attempt to achieve power and prestige without merit."
"The success of capitalism has everything to do with failure. People talk about the wealth that capitalism creates, but the poverty that capitalism creates -- in capitalists, not in poor people -- is extremely important. When a business fails...there's a reason for the business failing. They're making a product that no one wants to buy. You don't come in there and save that product."
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
2:00 PM
0
comments
Labels: Humor
Sunday, July 5, 2009
The Education Bubble
"The next bubble to burst will be the education bubble. Make no mistake about it, education is big business and, like other big businesses, it is in big trouble. What people outside the education bubble don’t realize and people inside won’t admit is that many colleges and universities are in the same position that major banks and financial institutions are: their assets (endowments down 30-40 percent this year) are plummeting, their liabilities (debts) are growing, most of their costs are fixed and rising, and their income (return on investments, support from government and private donations, etc.) is falling...
One of the dirty secrets of many research universities is that they treat master’s students as cash cows that fund other activities. To make matters worse, with many faculty members uninterested in teaching, students cannot assume they will get what they are paying for."
Mark C. Taylor, chairman of the religion department at Columbia University, writing in the New York Times.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
1:50 PM
0
comments
Labels: Education
The Next Bubble?
"Consumers who have questioned whether it is worth spending $1,000 a square foot for a home are now asking whether it is worth spending $1,000 a week to send their kids to college. There is a growing sense among the public that higher education might be overpriced and under-delivering."
"Will Higher Education Be the Next Bubble to Burst?" The Chronicle of Higher Education
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
10:03 AM
0
comments
Labels: Education
Saturday, July 4, 2009
This Execrable Commerce
In his first draft of the Declaration of Independence, Thomas Jefferson tried to address the issue of slavery, but it was edited out of the final copy by Georgia and South Carolina in the messy process of political compromise.
Here are the words Jefferson originally wrote, himself a slave owner, though not a willing one.
"...he [the king of Great Britain] has waged cruel war against human nature itself, violating it’s most sacred rights of life & liberty in the persons of a distant people who never offended him, captivating & carrying them into slavery in another hemisphere, or to incur miserable death in their transportation thither. This piratical warfare, the opprobrium of infidel powers, is the warfare of the CHRISTIAN king of Great Britain. Determined to keep open a market where MEN should be bought & sold, he has prostituted his negative for suppressing every legislative attempt to prohibit or to restrain this execrable commerce: and that this assemblage of horrors might want no fact of distinguished die, he is now exciting those very people to rise in arms among us, and to purchase that liberty of which he has deprived them, by murdering the people upon whom he also obtruded them; thus paying off former crimes committed against the liberties of one people, with crimes which he urges them to commit against the lives of another. In every stage of these oppressions we have petitioned."
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
10:27 AM
0
comments
Labels: Politics
Government of the Least Expense
"Society in every state is a blessing, but government even in its best state is but a necessary evil; in its worst state an intolerable one; for when we suffer, or are exposed to the same miseries BY A GOVERNMENT, which we might expect in a country WITHOUT GOVERNMENT, our calamity is heightened by reflecting that we furnish the means by which we suffer. Government, like dress, is the badge of lost innocence; the palaces of kings are built on the ruins of the bowers of paradise. For were the impulses of conscience clear, uniform, and irresistibly obeyed, man would need no other lawgiver; but that not being the case, he finds it necessary to surrender up a part of his property to furnish means for the protection of the rest; and this he is induced to do by the same prudence which in every other case advises him out of two evils to choose the least. WHEREFORE, security being the true design and end of government, it unanswerably follows that whatever FORM thereof appears most likely to ensure it to us, with the least expence and greatest benefit, is preferable to all others."
Thomas Paine, Common Sense, 1776
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
10:09 AM
0
comments
Labels: Politics
Bind Him Down From Mischief
Harper's has a superb quotation from Thomas Jefferson, perfect for the Fourth of July.
"It would be a dangerous delusion were a confidence in the men of our choice to silence our fears for the safety of our rights; that confidence is every where the parent of despotism; free government is founded in jealousy, and not in confidence; it is jealousy, and not confidence, which prescribes limited constitutions to bind down those whom we are obliged to trust with power; that our Constitution has accordingly fixed the limits to which, and no farther, our confidence may go; and let the honest advocate of confidence read the Alien and Sedition Acts, and say if the Constitution has not been wise in fixing limits to the government it created, and whether we should be wise in destroying those limits; let him say what the government is, if it be not a tyranny, which the men of our choice have conferred on the President, and the President of our choice has assented to and accepted, over the friendly strangers, to whom the mild spirit of our country and its laws had pledged hospitality and protection; that the men of our choice have more respected the bare suspicions of the President than the solid rights of innocence, the claims of justification, the sacred force of truth, and the forms and substance of law and justice. In questions of power, then, let no more be said of confidence in man, but bind him down from mischief by the chains of the Constitution."
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
8:31 AM
0
comments
Labels: Politics
Thursday, July 2, 2009
A Rigged Game
Darryl Campbell, a Ph.D. candidate in history, has published a sneering obituary for Billy Mays, the hard-working television pitchman who died last month.
Campbell's carefully phrased criticisms ring with intellectual condescension:
"...the loudest practitioner of the old-school hard sell."
"...cookie-cutter ads and the questionably useful devices and chemicals he peddled."
"...he still existed mainly to give us sincere advice about problems we didn't even know we had."
"But the aw-shucks, nice-guy persona, all smiles and shouts, hid a cunning businessman who was fully aware that his persona was every bit a fetish as the trinkets he sold."
"...professional huckster."
"...he promised that acquiring superfluous junk could be a ticket to a better life, even at a time when that life seems to be slipping further and further out of reach for so many of us."
How ironic that Campbell should sneer at Billy Mays, when Campbell himself is purchasing what may the world's most questionably useful degree.
William A. Pannapacker, Ph.D. in English, writes about the academic profession for the Chronicle of Higher Education. In a recent column, he pointed out that only half of all doctorate holders in the humanities -- after nearly a decade of preparation -- will ever find a tenure-track position, the academic equivalent of a full time job.
Pannapacker warns aspiring humanities graduate students, "What almost no prospective graduate students can understand is the extent to which doctoral education in the humanities socializes idealistic, naïve, and psychologically vulnerable people into a profession with a very clear set of values. It teaches them that life outside of academe means failure, which explains the large numbers of graduates who labor for decades as adjuncts, just so they can stay on the periphery of academe."
Given a choice of professional values, I choose the values of the salesman over the values of the professor. The motives of the salesman are transparent. He wants the customer to buy. The values of the professor are carefully disguised. Behind the veneer of scholarly inquiry, he wants to exploit "naïve, and psychologically vulnerable people." Under the noble banner of knowledge, he promises that a superfluous degree is the ticket to a better life. Who is the better huckster here?
Professor Pannapacker concludes, "It's hard to tell young people that universities recognize that their idealism and energy — and lack of information — are an exploitable resource. For universities, the impact of graduate programs on the lives of those students is an acceptable externality, like dumping toxins into a river. If you cannot find a tenure-track position, your university will no longer court you; it will pretend you do not exist and will act as if your unemployability is entirely your fault. It will make you feel ashamed, and you will probably just disappear, convinced it's right rather than that the game was rigged from the beginning."
If Billy Mays really did sell some crap, at least it wasn't as individually expensive or socially toxic as the crap universities are selling some graduate students in the humanities.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:53 AM
1 comments
Labels: Business
Dissecting Health Care Plans
Health care reform is in the air again, and this short video from the Cato Institute frames the issue nicely.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Health Care
Wednesday, July 1, 2009
Business and Slavery
The Financial Times reports that Rothschild, the merchant bank, and Freshfields, the City law firm, are the first UK businesses to say they “greatly regret” their links with slavery.
In the United States, JPMorgan and Aetna have already apologized for slavery. Several states have passed laws that require companies to disclose any links they had with slavery.
With all this apologizing going on, you might get the impression that human slavery and business were really the same thing. Perhaps that is precisely the motive of those who demand such apologies. If their goal is to undermine the moral legitmacy of business, what better way than to connect business with such a reprehensible institution?
Connecting slavery and business may be effective politics, but it is awful history. The truth is that the campaign to end human slavery was, in the words of Thomas Sowell, "spearheaded by people who would today be called "the religious right" and [the anti-slavery] organization was created by conservative businessmen. Moreover, what destroyed slavery in the non-Western world was Western imperialism."
Sowell explains why those who go around demanding apologies for slavery do not acknowledge the real history of the fight to end the institution: "nothing could be more jolting and discordant with the vision of today's intellectuals than the fact that it was businessmen, devout religious leaders and Western imperialists who together destroyed slavery around the world."
The world we live in was built with so many immoral acts that blaming other people is easy. What is hard is giving the credit for good deeds to people you don't like. Slavery was a business, but business was not slavery.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
8:50 AM
0
comments
Labels: Business

