Tuesday, June 19, 2007

Planning, Financial and Otherwise

No one ever walks into a financial planner's office and asks for an expensive, complicated, and difficult to maintain financial plan. What he wants is something simple, effective, and as inexpensive as possible.

The same is true for every other kind of plan. Business plans, military plans, and education plans are all ideally simple, effective, and inexpensive. Another way of saying this is to describe the plan as "economical," in the sense it uses a minimum of the resources required. These resources might be time, knowledge, or money, among other things.

Remarkably, more than just human plans seem to be organized with the goal of economy. Consider the human mind. It works with a surprisingly small amount of information. Our senses do not completely perceive reality as it is. Rather, our senses detect only those facets of reality that aid our survival. You could say our senses operate economically.

Trade extends the idea of economy to the relationship between individuals. In a trading economy, individuals can achieve a great deal of success with a surprisingly limited amount of knowledge. All that is necessary is the entrepreneurial sense to detect a trading opportunity, the freedom to trade, and a price system that reflects unbiased information.

To return to our initial argument, we should never ask for an economic system that is expensive, complicated and difficult to maintain. The more we allow market forces to work, the closer we come to the ideal of an adaptable system that operates effectively with widely dispersed and individually limited knowledge.

Monday, June 18, 2007

Freedom, Not Climate, Is at Risk

More and more businesses are jumping on the global warming band-wagon. Why? Do they think it's good for business? Do they see an opportunity to make a profit for their owners and shareholders? Do they think it's good PR? Or do they feel compelled by conscience to do what they think is right?

I suspect it is a mixture of all of the above. A business is nothing more than a temporary overlap of a wide variety of self interests. People work and do things for their own peculiar motives, not necessarily yours or mine. The amazing thing is that we work together so well and so often.

But whatever the motive, before business accepts the responsibility to do what it can to avoid a man-made climate catastrophe, it should consider the words of Vaclav Klaus. Although he is an elected politician, President of the Czech Republic, he bravely speaks about the danger behind global warm-and-fuzzy feelings. An excerpt:

"As someone who lived under communism for most of his life, I feel obliged to say that I see the biggest threat to freedom, democracy, the market economy and prosperity now in ambitious environmentalism, not in communism. This ideology wants to replace the free and spontaneous evolution of mankind by a sort of central (now global) planning."

And another:

"I agree with Professor Richard Lindzen from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, who said: “future generations will wonder in bemused amazement that the early 21st century’s developed world went into hysterical panic over a globally averaged temperature increase of a few tenths of a degree, and, on the basis of gross exaggerations of highly uncertain computer projections combined into implausible chains of inference, proceeded to contemplate a roll-back of the industrial age”."

Business should approach the issue of global warming with great skepticism. It is an issue where science, politics, and propaganda have mixed to a dangerous degree.

Sunday, June 17, 2007

One Radical to Another

The following is my response to an editorial by Brad Warthen, Editorial Page Editor of "The State" newspaper in Columbia, SC. Brad is a friend with whom I have friendly disagreements. One of the things I disagree with is his fondness for the phrases "strident libertarian" and "radical libertarian."

Brad,

Frankly I'm puzzled at the way you casually dismiss anyone who disagrees with you as a "strident libertarian," while strenuously resisting any attempt to identify yourself a "strident communitarian." Don't you think it's a little hypocritical?

As for those you label "libertarian," you should be aware that it includes a rather diverse community. Reagan Republicans, moderate libertarians, anarcho-capitalists, evangelical Christians, and even some conservative Democrats share many of the views you dismiss under one label.

I do not doubt your sincerity in wishing for a better world. We share that wish. However, what I do worry about is your enthusiasm for using political power to mold a particular vision of the social order. As F.A. Hayek pointed out sixty years ago in "The Road to Serfdom," people with good intentions believe political power can improve the world, and end up discovering that political power is quickly usurped by those who use it for their own ruthless ends. This explains much of the pointless suffering of the 20th century.

And before you dismiss Hayek as a "strident libertarian," you should know he resisted the label. He repudiated conservatism and was sympathetic to socialism (a careful reading of "The Road to Serfdom" reveals a social policy not too different from the Democrat Party Platform of 1992). Hayek preferred to call himself "an Old Whig," a term I think we should revive for its quirkiness, if for no other reason.

Ben Rast
President, The Bastiat Society
Treasurer, The SC Club for Growth
www.bastiatblog.blogspot.com
www.scclubforgrowth.com

Saturday, June 16, 2007

"Cute Depreciates Rapidly"

Stephen Colbert, the funniest guy on television, gives advice on the weak dollar, your next vacation, the ivory trade, and where to invest. It's a virtuoso performance.

Warning: this material is not intended for use.

Friday, June 15, 2007

The Bastiat Society Honors Atkins and Gornik

The Bastiat Society is pleased to announce that Paul Atkins, Commissioner of the Securities and Exchange Commission in Washington, DC, and Kathy Gornik, President of Thiel Audio in Lexington, Kentucky, are recipients of Bastiat Awards. Mr. Atkins will receive the Bastiat in Public Policy Award, and Ms. Gornik will receive the Bastiat in Business Award. The awards will be presented at a gala dinner in Charleston, South Carolina on Saturday, April 5th, 2008.

The Bastiat Awards are given in four areas: Public Policy, Culture, Academics, and Business. The awards honor individuals who, in the course of their professional lives, have distinguished themselves in promoting free market ideas and a greater appreciation of the socially beneficial and inherently moral nature of peaceful commercial activity.

The Society and the awards are named after the French economist Frédéric Bastiat (1801 – 1850), one of the all-time great spokesmen for classical liberalism, who was famous for his ability to translate complex economic ideas into language anyone could understand.

For more information, please contact Stephanie Whitener.

Image property of Walter O. LeCroy

Thursday, June 14, 2007

The Power of Choice

Bob Chitester will be the speaker at the July Bastiat Society monthly meeting.

Mr. Chitester is President and CEO of the Palmer R. Chitester Fund, Chitester Creative Associates, Inc. and The Idea Channel®; and is managing partner of Free to Choose Enterprise. These companies produce television programs and program elements, create and operate web sites, create print and CD-ROM materials, and distribute curriculum materials to high schools and colleges.

Date: Wednesday, 11 July 2007
Hors d'oeuvres : 5:00 pm
Speaker: 6:00 pm
Location: Imaging Arts Gallery 175 King Street, Charleston, SC
RSVP to Stephanie Whitener

In 1977, Mr. Chitester convinced Milton Friedman to undertake a project which became, Free to Choose, an award winning PBS TV series and an international best selling book based on the series. Over 25 years later the series and book are still in wide use and have been notably influential. Mart Laar, first Prime Minister of a free Estonia and recent winner of the Friedman Prize, used Free to Choose as a guide in setting policies that gave Estonia a thriving economy.

The Palmer R. Chitester Fund is a 501-c-3 public foundation doing business as izzit.org (formerly In the Classroom Media) and Free to Choose Media. Its mission is: To use easily understood and entertaining popular media to reach inquisitive minds regarding the value and interrelationship of personal, economic and political freedom sustained by the rule of law.

izzit.org created the Stossel in the Classroom teaching units and services a nationwide network of teachers in over 68% of all secondary schools in the United States. Currently over 84,000 teachers use these and new video materials developed by izzit.org to supplement classroom curriculum for over 13 million students.

Free to Choose Media recently completed production of The Power of Choice a television biography of Milton Friedman to be telecast on PBS. In the works are several other programs, including a biography of Secretary of State George Shultz and commentaries by and about Hernando de Soto and Bjorn Lomborg.

In the mid nineties, working with TCI in Denver, Chitester Creative Associates, Inc. created Damn Right, a week-nightly, half-hour program, whose alumni, include David Asman, Eric Burns and Douglas Kennedy, currently regulars on the Fox Cable News Channel, Jonathan Karl of ABC news, and Richard Loury, editor of National Review. Another production, “National School Assembly,” with David Robinson, MVP Center with the San Antonio Spurs, is currently being offered to teachers via izzit.org.

The Idea Channel is a library of over 200 video recordings of intellectual discussions between the world's leading scholars, the collection currently includes more than 50 Nobel Prize recipients, including Friedrich von Hayek, Jim Buchanan, Christian de Duve, Norman Borlaug and Charles Townes.

Along with Milton and Rose Friedman, Mr. Chitester is the managing partner of Free To Choose Enterprise. Free To Choose Enterprise manages licensing and sales of “Free to Choose,” hosted by Professor Friedman, 1976 Nobel prize winning economist.

Mr. Chitester has more than forty five years of experience in television management and program development. He started educational television facilities at Buena Vista High School in Saginaw, Michigan and Edinboro State University in Pennsylvania. In 1966, he became the founding General Manager of the Erie, Pennsylvania PBS and NPR stations (WQLN and WQLN-FM), which he headed until 1982.

Mr. Chitester earned his B.A. and M.A. degrees from the University of Michigan, and received an honorary Doctor of Literature degree from Allegheny College. He and his wife, Carol Lovell, have four children and eight grandchildren.

Image © 2006 Free to Choose Media. All Rights Reserved.

The Cost of Regulation

In ancient Athens, a lawmaker was held personally responsible for the results of any legislation he proposed. If his ideas turned our badly, he could be fined, imprisoned, or even executed.

Now that's accountability. It's what they meant in ancient Athens when they talked about "an inconvenient truth."

In modern Washington, there is a somewhat less enthusiastic effort to make lawmakers and government agencies accountable for the costs of implementing their proposed regulations. Businesses have run cost/benefit analyses for years, but in Washington, the idea of being held responsible is about as popular as uncensored speech on a college campus. No wonder. It's much easier to make up laws and regulations if you never have to worry about costs or benefits.

Check out what the Washington Post says.

Wednesday, June 13, 2007

Ce qu'on voit et ce qu'on ne vois pas

One of Frédéric Bastiat's famous essays is "Ce qu'on voit et ce qu'on ne vois pas," in English, "That Which is Seen and That Which is Not Seen." In it, he argued that we often make the mistake of focusing only on the immediate and visible result of our actions without ever thinking about what we do not see. Bastiat wrote:

"Between a good and a bad economist this constitutes the whole difference - the one takes account of the visible effect; the other takes account both of the effects which are seen, and also of those which it is necessary to foresee. Now this difference is enormous, for it almost always happens that when the immediate consequence is favourable, the ultimate consequences are fatal, and the converse. Hence it follows that the bad economist pursues a small present good, which will be followed by a great evil to come, while the true economist pursues a great good to come, - at the risk of a small present evil."

Even today, over 150 years after Bastiat's death, we still find intelligent people making the mistake of only thinking about the benefits they can see. Teenagers, politicians, broadcasters and real estate agents are notorious for doing this.

For example, in 2006, NPR reported on the improvements in Charleston, SC brought about by the devastation of Hurricane Hugo. Some people call the hurricane -- which caused billions of dollars of damage -- "the best thing that ever happened to Charleston" because it brought an insurance-fueled rebuilding boom.

They could see the boom. But they could not foresee its consequences. Now, homeowners and politicians along the South Carolina coast are up in arms because insurance companies are hiking their rates to cover the risk of another hurricane. Multi-million dollar homes now stand on some of the most geologically unstable and storm-exposed real estate in the world. The next hurricane to hit the coast won't hit throw-away, week-enders. It will pound prime real estate, and will cause damage many times the cost of Hugo. The insurance companies know this, and are adjusting their rates accordingly.

It was their money that rebuilt Charleston last time. It's their money that is at stake today.

Tuesday, June 12, 2007

To the Benefit of the Ordinary Person

"The rich in Ancient Greece would have benefited little from modern plumbing: running servants replaced running water. Television and radio -- the patricians of Rome could enjoy the leading musicians and actors in their home, could have the leading artists as domestic retainers. Ready-to-wear clothing, supermarkets -- all these and many other modern developments would have added little to their life. They would have welcomed the improvements in transportation and in medicine, but for the rest, the great achievements of Western capitalism have redounded primarily to the benefit of the ordinary person."

Milton Friedman in Free to Choose
Quoted in A Conflict of Visions by Thomas Sowell

Image © 2007 The J. Paul Getty Trust. All rights reserved.

Monday, June 11, 2007

Horror Shows, Real and Imagined

Believe it or not, there are intellectuals out there who claim zombie movies are perfect parables for what happens in market economies. Think Consumer-Without-a-Soul + Profit-Seeking-Business = Flesh Eating Zombie and you've got the basic argument.

If you doubt me -- and I didn't believe it myself until I checked the facts -- check out Reason magazine's piece on the politics of zombie flicks. Tim Cavanaugh writes:

"In his 1979 study The American Nightmare: Essays on the Horror Film, the esteemed cineaste Robin Wood declared that the zombie’s cannibalism “represents the ultimate in possessiveness, hence the logical end of human relations under capitalism.” "

Just goes to show you that there is nothing so ridiculous that it cannot be found in movie reviews.

While Robin Wood et. al. were sitting in dark theaters, munching on buttered popcorn and looking for capitalist bogeymen, there was a real world horror show playing in places like Albania. For nearly fifty years, Albania was a Stalinist worker's paradise, where murder, cruelty and paranoia were the only things ever produced. Robin Wood imagined horror. Albania lived it.

Albania has emerged from its real-live horror show and is trying to build a new social order. It may be the only country where they don't just like Americans, they're crazy about them. After nearly half a century of lies and secret police in leather coats, the Albanians aren't too worried about "the logical end of human relations under capitalism."

They've seen another ending. They don't want it anymore.

Sunday, June 10, 2007

The Age of Abundance

In Brink Lindsey's new book, The Age of Abundance: How Prosperity Transformed America's Politics and Culture, he argues that the unrivaled economic prosperity of the last century fused the old left/right political split into a generally libertarian consensus.

One interesting result: complacency became a consumer good. Check out his interview with Jon Stewart on The Daily Show.


Saturday, June 9, 2007

The Trouble with Socialism

"The trouble with socialism is socialism. The trouble with capitalism is capitalists."

Austrian analyst Willi Schlamm, quoted "every ten years" by William F. Buckley

Friday, June 8, 2007

A Long Term Investment

Business is often criticized for dwelling on short-term results. When the criticism comes from an important intellectual defender of free markets like Milton Friedman, business should pay attention.

"I have been impressed time and again by the schizophrenic character of many businessmen. They are capable of being extremely far-sighted and clear-headed in matters that are internal to their businesses. They are incredibly short-sighted and muddle-headed in matters that are outside their businesses but affect the possible survival of business in general."

Milton Friedman
"The Social Responsibility of Business is to Increase its Profits"
The New York Times Magazine
September 13, 1970

If business people do not invest in the long-term ideas that make business success possible, who will?

Image courtesy of www.freetochoosemedia.org

Thursday, June 7, 2007

The Nature of Business

Business is told that it must be many things to many people. It must be a good corporate citizen and support the arts and the non-profit community. It must support environmental causes like global warming and recycling. It must increase diversity by its hiring and promotion policies. It must be a partner of governments -- local, state, and federal -- for all manner of projects, from job creation to smart growth. It must not make mistakes. It must be a strategic partner of public education.

Somewhere in this list, the most important thing business must do has been lost: business must maximize owner value over the long term by selling goods or services. That is what makes an organization a business and not something else.

This definition comes from Elaine Sternberg, formerly Research Fellow in Philosophy at the Centre for Business and Professional Ethics, University of Leeds.

If an organization tries to be all things to all people, it cannot be much of anything at all, and least of all a business. Strictly defining a business makes the organizational task more manageable and therefore more likely to succeed.

But business success attracts attention -- and envy. In a world with many needs and a limited ability to pay for them, it is very tempting to tack on additional obligations to the organizations that are most effective at creating wealth.

The great danger we face is that by overloading business with new and often contradictory obligations, even with the best intentions, we risk destroying both wealth and the social arrangement that creates it.

Wednesday, June 6, 2007

Principles of Economics, Translated

If you've ever felt like you needed a translator to understand an economist, you'll enjoy this video featuring the world's first and only Stand Up Economist. He uses a combination of logic, humor, and irreverence to translate the principles of economics into language we all understand.

Tuesday, June 5, 2007

Business for the Benefit of Mankind

In 1733, Voltaire, the French writer and general troublemaker for French royalty, published his Letters Concerning the English Nation. His description of business as a social institution of tolerance and mutual benefit has rarely been surpassed.

"Take a view of the Royal Exchange in London, a place more venerable than many courts of justice, where the representatives of all nations meet for the benefit of mankind. There the Jew, the Mahometan, and the Christian transact together, as though they all professed the same religion, and give the name of infidel to none but bankrupts. There thee Presbyterian confides in the Anabaptist, and the Churchman depends on the Quaker's word. At the breaking up of this pacific and free assembly, some withdraw to the synagogue, and others to take a glass. This man goes and is baptized in a great tub, in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost: that man has his son's foreskin cut off, whilst a set of Hebrew words (quite unintelligible to him) are mumbled over his child. Others retire to their churches, and there wait for the inspiration of heaven with their hats on, and all are satisfied.

If one religion only were allowed in England, the Government would very possibly become arbitrary; if there were but two, the people would cut one another's throats; but as there are such a multitude, they all live happy and in peace."

Monday, June 4, 2007

What Does the Bastiat Society Aim to Accomplish?

The Bastiat Society’s mission is to accomplish five socially important goals:

1. Defend business people as the most important agents of human material progress. They are the real anti-poverty heroes.

2. Explain the virtuous and moral role that business people serve in market economies. They are ethical leaders.

3. Improve the business community’s appreciation and understanding of the necessity for a large, international, and influential class of intellectuals sympathetic to capitalism. Ideas are capitalism’s main defense.

4. Redirect the philanthropic flow of business-created wealth to institutions that will defend and promote capitalism – rather than work to destroy it.

5. Promote our members’ businesses, by building an international network of the highest quality, integrity and mutual respect. The Society is a place to do first-class business.

The Society accomplishes its mission through monthly meetings, its web site and blog, conferences, and the Bastiat Society Awards in Public Policy, Culture, Business and Academics.

Sunday, June 3, 2007

Business and High Profile Philanthropy

If the first rule of business is “It takes money to make money,” the second rule is fast becoming “Then give it all away.” Ted Turner started the current round of high-profile philanthropy in 1997 with a $1 billion gift to support the work of the UN. The Gates Foundation, philanthropic child of Bill and Melinda Gates, has $30 billion in assets. And Warren Buffet has pledged 85% of his $44 billion fortune to philanthropy.

Noble actions, yes. Philanthropy is a conspicuous good deed. But business improves the world in ways immeasurably more important than what it gives away.

Every day, we take thousands of business goods and services for granted, from wi-fi, to coffee, to restaurants, just to name a few. Every day, we wake up in a world where strangers work hard to offer us many of the things we want, even if we have not yet decided that we want them. We don’t know where we will eat lunch, but we are confident that someone will work with no guarantee of success to give us that choice. Business does this not because it is philanthropic, but because business serves its own interest by serving ours. Great fortunes are built by satisfying the needs of a great many people, one at a time.

In isolation, such small measures of satisfaction are easily overlooked. But added together from all the individuals involved, they reveal a world that is more satisfied, more cooperative, less violent, and wealthier. The sum of business activity is a better world.

To the extent that business philanthropy is described as “giving back,” it obscures the fundamentally beneficial nature of commercial activity. To the extent that philanthropy is described as business’s most important role in improving the world, it flatly contradicts the facts. To the extent that philanthropy funds individuals and organizations that oppose business, it funds the most dangerous opponents of human progress.

Anyone who wants to really improve the world should stick to what works. First, build an honest and profitable business that takes good care of its most reliable employees, suppliers and customers. Second, when the urge to give it all away strikes, consider whether the gift will promote or destroy the kind of world that made success possible in the first place.

Image property of Walter O. LeCroy

Saturday, June 2, 2007

The Corporate Welfare State

Last year, the US government handed out over $92 billion to politically favored corporations, according to Stephen Slivinski at the Cato Institute. This money didn't buy anything. It was a handout disguised by the use of the word "investment." It's more accurately called corporate welfare.

Frankly, this is the kind of thing that gives capitalism a bad name. The image of businessmen lining up in Washington with their hands out does not inspire great confidence in either business or the men themselves.

The usual arguments in favor of corporate welfare are:
1. Some businesses need help because of market failures.
2. Government can pick winners.

The track record of government success in "correcting market failure" is pretty poor. Sometimes, a business fails because it is simply the wrong business with the wrong management at the wrong time. To call that kind of failure a market failure is a cop-out. To hand that kind of business a big check from the taxpayer is nuts.

The track record of government picking winners is even worse. If government was really just as good as venture capital at picking winners, we wouldn't be using Google today, we'd be using Googleski -- invented in the USSR, a country that tried harder to pick winners than any other.

Check out Stephen Slivinski in this podcast.

Image property of Walter O. LeCroy

Friday, June 1, 2007

The Impact of the Highly Improbable

In 1962, an unknown guy in an unknown town started a little business that was...well, unknown.

Today, everyone knows his name: Sam Walton. The business is Wal-Mart.

Who predicted his success? I doubt even Sam Walton himself knew what lay ahead. In 1962, the giants of the retail market in the US were Montgomery Ward (it went bankrupt) and Sears (it got beat by K-Mart, which went bankrupt). No wonder Sam Walton was famous for down-to-earth humility. He surely realized how improbable his success really was.

Any rational human surveying the retail business in 1962 would have said Wal-Mart had no chance. And he would have been wrong. Rational, but wrong.

Many times in business, we are faced with the impact of highly improbable events, what you might call the defeat of reason. This is the subject of two intriguing books, Fooled by Randomness and The Black Swan, by Nassim Nicholas Taleb.

All too often, we see more certainty in numbers than is really there. This is especially true in accounting and stock prices. Math makes things manageable, but it does not make them predictable. At least not as predictable as events in physics or chemistry.

For more on Taleb, check out a discussion of his work in The Economist and an interview on NPR.

Article in The Economist

NPR interview

Thursday, May 31, 2007

The McFacts About McJobs

Language is one of the best examples of a spontaneous human order. It occurs naturally. It quickly adapts to new circumstances. It is not the result of any one person's conscious design. And it stubbornly resists political tampering.

Nevertheless, the temptation to intervene in the natural order of language often proves irresistible, whether for political or other reasons. Consider what the editors at the Oxford English Dictionary have done to the word "McJob." The OED defines "McJob" as a dead-end job for an overqualified candidate who can't find something better.

The OED claims to be objectively documenting how people use the word. However, there are at least three documented uses of "McJob." Two are positive, and only one is negative. Yet, the OED never mentions the positive usages.

According to John Blundell, Director General of the Institute of Economic Affairs:

"...in a decade of studying McJobs I have found three different definitions. McJob was first used in Los Angeles in 1985 when a franchise holder adapted his restaurant so that disabled people could work there. So the earliest definition would be "a job specially created by the world's most admired food service company at great cost to give disabled people opportunities not normally available to them."Then there is the pejorative McJob as in the dead end label and finally there is the positive McJob as in McJobbers actually go further in life than their peers."

In choosing to feature only the negative definition, could the editors of the OED be guilty of an anti-American, anti-business bias? Even if they are innocent of political bias, they are certainly ignoring the career opportunities that stretch before every entry-level McDonald's employee. Every shift has a supervisor. Every supervisor has a manager. Every manager has a store. Every store belongs to a franchisee. Every franchisee works with corporate headquarters. Eventually, there are senior management positions, a CEO, and the board of directors. All of these can be reasonably called "McJobs."

In other words, there are no dead end jobs, only dead end imaginations. It is disheartening to find them at the esteemed OED.

For an analysis of the benefits of a McJob, check out John Blundell's paper McJob, McCheque, McWonderful.


Wednesday, May 30, 2007

Why Americans Are Confused

The Bastiat Society invites you to our monthly meeting next Wednesday, June 6th. We welcome Dr. Edward Hudgins, the executive director of The Atlas Society and publisher of that organization's magazine, The New Individual.


Dr. Hudgins' topic for the evening is:

"Why Americans Are Confused About Freedom and What We Can Do About It"

Ever notice that many Americans in the same breath will declare their support for free markets and for restricting gasoline "price-gouging," or for free speech and limits on political messages sponsored by "special interest groups?"

We all know the reasons why governments should be limited to protecting our lives, liberty and property. But too often those reasons fall on deaf ears because of the intellectual and moral confusion or the serious blind spots of many Americans, including those in the business community.

A review of some of the most common errors will help us better make the case for freedom to the widest audience.

Please RSVP at 843.577.7501 or email stephanie.whitener@imagingarts.com
175 King Street, Charleston, SC
5pm – 6pm Drinks and Hors d'oeuvres by Tristan
6pm – 7pm Presentation and discussion

Koch CEO Says Business Must Show Leadership

In an interview in the Financial Times, Charles Koch, CEO of the largest privately held business in the world , calls business people to task for meekly accepting more regulation and taxation:

"They [business people] need to stand up and say: 'Guys, you do this [increase regulation and raise taxes] and it is going to hurt our ability to create value and create prosperity and make your lives better.' The leaders in business should show some leadership instead of being just victims....

What happens when the public loses faith that business people are creating value, if it starts saying, 'Well let's tax them all, let's take it away. If they are making our lives worse rather than better, who needs them?'"

Read his entire interview here.

Tuesday, May 29, 2007

Business Owns the Moral High Ground

"The Bastiat Society was organized to promote awareness in the business community that the world is getting better, and it’s commerce that’s doing it. Trade is a fundamental and virtuous human activity.Those who trade are not villains, but are the actual owners of the moral high ground. Instead of abandoning it to glib academics, politicians, and other condescending pretenders who usually frame the terms of the debate, the business community should speak up and reclaim the moral high ground."

Walter O. LeCroy

Founder, Board Member, and Retired CEO of The LeCroy Corporation
Co-founder and Chairman of The Bastiat Society

Monday, May 28, 2007

What Will They Tax Next?

This video from 18 Doughty Street in the UK speaks for itself. A video is worth a thousand words.

Sunday, May 27, 2007

Capitalists, Not Pilgrims, Founded America

America was founded by capitalists seeking a profit, not Pilgrims seeking religious freedom. English settlers founded Jamestown in 1607 as "a joint stock company looking for gold," says journalist and Virginia native Bob Deans.

The Pilgrims landed thirteen years later.

So why hasn't the capitalist origin of the American nation received more attention? Deans says it's because founding a nation on religious freedom sounds nobler than founding a nation on the desire to make a buck.

And there was a little regional jealousy at work after the Civil War. The victorious North didn't want to cede the creation of America to the vanquished South, and least of all, to the heart of the Confederacy, Virginia.

Saturday, May 26, 2007

Study Finds BBC is Too Easy On Business

The BBC's coverage of business isn't critical enough, according to an independent review, reported by TheFinancial Times.

The report found no systematic bias against business. However, it did express concerns about business journalism that was a little too friendly. The report highlighted an interview with Bill Gates that it said was "at times sycophantic in tone." It also pointed out a number of interviews with Stuart Rose, CEO of Marks and Spencer as being "too uncritical."

No doubt this comes as a great surprise to business people. They didn't realize the BBC was such a chum.

For a different opinion on bias at the BBC, check out this interview with Robin Aitken, author of the book Can We Trust the BBC? Mr. Aitken spent 25 years at the BBC.

The video comes from 18Doughty Street, a UK web site that advertises itself as "politics for adults."

Friday, May 25, 2007

Legal Sanity "Discovered"

Professor Richard Epstein, of the University of Chicago School of Law, says the U.S. Supreme Court may have started "a welcome revolution in civil litigation."

In an editorial in The Wall Street Journal (24 May 2007), Professor Epstein discusses the implications of the Court's dismissal of an anti-trust class-action suit against telephone companies, Twombly v Bell Atlantic, without requiring the expensive and time consuming legal process known as "discovery."

All too often, defendants find it easier and less expensive to settle a case rather than submit to discovery, even if the case against them is flimsy. This might be a practical solution, but it isn't justice.

In the Twombly case, the Court dismissed the case without discovery and saved "millions in legal fees and potential billions in treble damage awards." This decision marks a break with a long-standing interpretation of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure that allowed each party to probe its rival's case before going to trial.

It's too early to tell whether the thinking behind this dismissal will spread to other class-action lawsuits. But it is a step in the right direction. Anyone who wants to start a class-action lawsuit should be prepared to justify the costs in terms of time and money.

In addition to his many honors, Professor Epstein is a member of the Advisory Board of The Bastiat Society.

Read his comments here.

Thursday, May 24, 2007

Fed Watching

Question: How do you get into Columbia Business School (CBS)?

Answer: With a sense of humor.

Check out this video, "Every Breath Bernanke Takes," sung to the tune of "Every Breath You Take" by The Police.

The singer is a student who looks like Glenn Hubbard, the Dean of CBS. After watching this, I think you'll agree these students are wasting their time in Business School. With a sense of humor like this, they should have their own show on CNBC.

Watching the Fed is a major entertainment industry around the world. It employs thousands of people who apply millions of kilowatts of some of the best available brain power, all trying to answer a simple question: are rates going up or down?

The old saying on Wall Street is, "There are only two people who know the direction of interest rates. Unfortunately, they don't agree."

Wednesday, May 23, 2007

Wealth and Sex, Part II

In the previous post, I argued that wealth is the ownership of socially desirable property. That assertion begs the question, "Is wealth, therefore, a limited resource?"

The answer is "It doesn't have to be." The great genius of the free market is that it allows humans to engage in wealth creation, an activity far more socially beneficial than wealth redistribution. Even if the benefits of wealth creation are skewed to the wealth creators themselves -- and who better deserves them -- the mere fact that wealth has been added to the world is nothing short of wonderful.

Wealth creation occurs when individuals pursue rational self-interest, engage in a division of labor, and trade freely among themselves, all under the rule of law. In other words, business creates wealth. On that basis alone, business is an institution of tremendous social benefit for mankind. Rather than attack business people as greedy, we should be celebrating business people as heroes.

However, when individuals pursue their own advantage at the expense of others, use force to assign and control the labor of others, and limit the freedom to trade, they engage in wealth destruction. This does, indeed, make wealth a limited -- and vanishing -- resource. Witness the history of Argentina.

At the time of the American revolution, Argentina was as prosperous as the new American nation. After generations of anti-business government policies and the inevitable destruction of vast and vital stores of wealth, modern Argentina finds itself in the precarious position of an emerging economy.

Emerging, yes. But only after a terrible and senseless submergence.

Image property of Walter O. LeCroy

Tuesday, May 22, 2007

Wealth and Sex, Part I

Humans think about wealth almost as much as they think about sex. Sex we know pretty well. But what, exactly, is wealth?


Wealth can be defined as the ownership of socially desirable property. This definition presupposes three things.

First, there must be a network of humans in social relationships. A man on a desert island cannot be wealthy. Wealth is a social phenomenon.

Second, there must be some kind of property law. It might be at the individual level, the family level, or even the small group level, but at some point, there must be a clear line drawn between "mine and yours" or "ours and theirs."

Third, the property in question must be desirable to other members of the society. Just because you have a lot of stuff and you really like it doesn't mean you're wealthy. Wealth is more than just what you like. Other people have to like it, too. The greater the number of people who like it, and the greater the intensity of their desire, the more valuable that property becomes. That's why an ounce of gold is more valuable than an ounce of silver. Value is a function of desire.

Once all of these conditions are met, humans can identify and accumulate wealth. That wealth might be measured in cows, cacao beans, baskets of fruit, bars of gold, stock certificates, brokerage statements or any of the thousands of other kinds of property humans have adopted as wealth throughout history and into the present day, but the essential nature of wealth remains the same: it is the ownership of socially desirable property. But that leaves us with another question. Why do humans desire wealth in the first place?

The answer is biological. There are two biological imperatives in the natural world. All life is driven by the desire to survive and the desire to successfully reproduce. Wealth enables humans to do both. At all times and in all societies, wealth is first and foremost a means survival. After that, it is a means of taking care of other socially important individuals.

In the final analysis, humans desire wealth because they want to live, and because they want to take care of other people who are important to them. And who are the most likely beneficiaries of their care? Why, their children, of course.

It turns out wealth and sex aren't so unrelated after all. Think about that the next time you think about...whatever.

Image property of Walter O. LeCroy

Monday, May 21, 2007

Does Pope Benedict Condemn Capitalism?

Major news services have reported that Pope Benedict XVI blasts capitalism for its "cruelty." But what does the Pope really think?

Socialism cannot save the poor. It produces "economic and ecological destruction." Its view of human history is contrary to the human heart. It tries to build a heavenly kingdom in this world.
Faith should not be politicized. Justice for the poor does not depend on a theology of ever more power for the state.

These are the views of Pope Benedict, as summarized by Father Sirico, a Catholic priest, in the pages of the Wall Street Journal Europe.

Father Sirico is the founder and President of the Acton Institute.

Image property of Walter O. LeCroy

Sunday, May 20, 2007

The Battle for the Soul of Capitalism

John C. "Jack" Bogle, the founder and former Chairman of the Vanguard Group, is known for speaking his mind clearly and unequivocally.

In his 2006 book, The Battle for the Soul of Capitalism, he draws a sharp distinction between the way capitalism worked in the past, when it was controlled by owners, and the way capitalism works today, when it is controlled by managers.

While publicly traded securities markets distribute shares of ownership over a large population, thereby giving more people the opportunity to participate in the historic returns on equity, publicly traded markets diffuse ownership and control, making it difficult if not impossible for the legitimate owners of a public company to have a significant say in running the company.

The result, according to Mr. Bogle, is a "pathological mutation" of capitalism that erodes the most essential social requirement for healthy financial markets: trust.

The solution is for shareholders, fiduciaries, and government regulators to act solely in the best interest of the actual owners of the company.

Listen to his comments here, introduced by Princeton professor Burton Malkiel.

Mr. Bogle is also an advocate of a liberal arts education (c.f., my post on "Business and the Liberal Arts").

Saturday, May 19, 2007

John Allison, CEO, Defends Moral Basis of Capitalism

John Allison, the CEO and Chairman of BB&T, the 11th largest financial holding company in the US, was the keynote speaker at the Atlas Economic Research Foundation's Liberty Forum in Philadelphia in May, 2007.

Allison said free markets have won the war of ideas, but only on a practical basis. It is far more important to win the war of ideas on a moral basis.

Listen to him here.

Friday, May 18, 2007

A Business Meeting to Remember

This video clip from "Saturday Night Live" should strike a chord with anyone who has suffered through at least one business meeting.

While peaceful commercial activity has done wonders for the world, it cannot eliminate human folly. Humanity is accident prone, in the boardroom, in the legislature, and on the battlefield.

The amazing thing is not that we live in a world with so many mistakes. Rather, it is that the world works so well.

When mistakes occur at the individual level, the consequences are often inconspicuous, at least to the rest of the world. When mistakes occur at the level of small groups (like the ones in the video), the mistakes are more visible, but the consequences are relatively contained. But when mistakes occur at the level of the state, two things happen.

First, thanks to the taxpayer, the mistakes acquire a much longer life. Second, the consequences are felt by everyone. Imagine, not a building imploding, but an entire nation-state, and you get the picture.

This leads us to an important conclusion: the most adaptable form of social organization is one that encourages risk-taking and mistake-making at the lowest social cost, i.e. at the individual level or the small-group level. In other words, social organizations that distribute decision-making, risk taking, and the information feedback we call failure will be more innovative and successful than social organizations that centralize decision making, risk-taking, and information feedback.

Thursday, May 17, 2007

A Moderately Well-Off Society

The Communist Party in China is shopping for some new ideological duds. They got rid of Marxism-as-we-know it in the late 1970s. They got rid of Mao suits in the 1990s. The Party gave the people one commandment, "Make as much money as you want, but leave politics alone." Then it sat back and watched the population spring into action.

Isn't it amazing what people will do once you stop making them wear their pajamas to work? And you stop seizing their property, threatening them with jail, and forcing them to attend re-education camps?

China is not an economic miracle. It is an example of what happens when individuals taste a little freedom. And that's exactly what worries the Party: where will all this stop?

In an effort wrap itself in a new ideology of authority and control, the Party is turning to China's great sage, Confucius. The Economist reports that Confucius is experiencing quite a revival in respectability and popularity, with the Party's blessing. The magazine reports:

"Since becoming China's top leader in 2002, President Hu Jintao has promoted a succession of official slogans, including “Harmonious Society” and “Xiaokang Shehui” (“a moderately well off society”), which have Confucian undertones."

When powerful governments stop talking about getting rich, and start talking about harmony and being moderately well-off, it is because they are threatened with imminent and overwhelming social change. This will be the next Chinese revolution.

Image courtesy of www.trendwatching.com

Wednesday, May 16, 2007

Texas Says "No" to Private Toll Roads

The Financial Times of 14 May 2007 reports that down in Texas, they don't have enough public money to build enough public roads to accommodate all the public that wants to drive on them.

The problem is fuel efficiency. As cars have become more fuel efficient, the amount of fuel tax received for every mile driven has dropped by half. Add to that a booming population, more traffic, and very little increase in road capacity, and you have the recipe for a Texas-sized case of gridlock.

The solution, at least for awhile, appeared to be private toll roads. These are roads built with private capital, not taxpayer dollars. The roads are owned by the state but leased to the private operators.

Private toll roads are a clear win-win for commuters and the state transportation authority: the commuter gets a choice (public and crowded roads or private and not crowded) and the state saves the cost of building and maintaining a road.

But, of course, in politics nothing works out the way you would expect.

The Texas House came up with its own plan to solve the problem. It passed a bill to eliminate the gas tax altogether for the summer. Then it approved a moratorium on privately built toll roads.

In effect, the House said it could solve the problem by bringing in less money, building its own toll roads, and by eliminating the competition. The details of this economic miracle remain unclear.

Meanwhile, somewhere in Texas, commuters are waiting...and waiting, and waiting.

For some cogent commentary on the roadblock in Texas, check out Robert Poole. Bob is one of the world's foremost experts on transportation privatization.

Bob was a speaker at the Bastiat Society in February, 2007.

Image courtesy of www.texasfreeway.com

Tuesday, May 15, 2007

Climate Control

In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, many intellectuals believed that scientific methodology, which had enjoyed incredible success in explaining and controlling the natural world, could be used to explain and control human society. Scientific theories of history and human society blossomed.

The 20th-century result was a horrible waste of precious time, money and lives.

What we learned from that painful experience is that human society is a complex, adaptive system that adjusts to new conditions in surprising ways and with unpredictable systematic consequences. The same is true for the economy, itself simply a subset of human society.

There is a growing body of study that focuses on the similarities of complex, adaptive systems. World climate is just such a system. Some aspects of climate are suitable for scientific analysis. For example, we can scientifically document the temperature, just as we can count the number of men and women in a population. As a result, there is no question that the climate is changing.

But can we scientifically attribute the cause of climate change, or scientifically control the direction of change, or scientifically guarantee there will be no unintended consequences? I believe our experience with complex, adaptive systems requires us to admit the answer to all of these questions is "No."

The only thing we can say for certain about a world-wide effort to control the climate is that, at best, it will be expensive and it might work. At worst, history will repeat itself, and it will be a horrible waste of time, money, and -- yes -- even lives.

Image property of Walter O. LeCroy

Monday, May 14, 2007

Got Hair?

Why should we be skeptical about embracing a national health care plan?

Check out what's happening in Germany, where the state-funded health insurance plan provides generous benefits like spa treatments.

A bald man had the nerve to ask the taxpayers to pay for his wig. The health plan said no. The bald man sued, but a court agreed with the health plan .

I guess you could say he wasn't covered.

Although this is a silly case, you can easily see how much time and money are wasted in a politicized system that is supposed to be more efficient than a consumer-driven system. Simple decisions like "Do I buy a hat, a wig or go bald" become "I deserve a wig and the government should pay for it."

Image property of Walter O. LeCroy

Sunday, May 13, 2007

Good Capitalism, Bad Capitalism

Dynamic change is a basic feature of a healthy economy. If new industries appear, and old ones disappear, the system is working the way it should

Arnold Kling, at Econlib, quotes an interesting fact from a new book "Good Capitalism, Bad Capitalism:"

Of the twenty-five largest firms in the United States in 1998, eight did not exist or were very small in 1960. In Europe, all twenty-five of the companies that were the largest in 1998 were already large in 1960.

Rather than spending precious time and money propping up big, old companies, we should be building an entrepreneurial economic system that encourages innovation and improvements. When business loses its entrepreneurial spark, it becomes a bureaucracy. And the safest thing to do at a bureaucracy is exactly what has always been done.

Saturday, May 12, 2007

Big Business Proposes Health Care Reform

Some interesting thoughts from Ronald Bailey in the pages of Reason magazine.

He asks a provocative question: is the proposed reform true market-based health care reform, i.e., one that places purchasing power in the hands of the health care consumer, or is it a worker -- and taxpayer -- rip off?

By the way, Ron Bailey spoke to the Bastiat Society in September of 2005.

Thursday, May 10, 2007

Political Gas

When gas prices go up, people use less. Higher prices eventually equal lower demand. No legislation required. No enforcement. No bureaucracy.

Of course, there is an inevitable delay in the adjustment. People logically wait to see if prices will come back down, or they wait until it is more economical to replace their current car with a more gas efficient model. Why buy a new car if you don't have to? A family can regulate the use of an old car -- even a gas guzzler -- far more efficiently than it can regulate the rapid depreciation of a new one.

Yet, impatient to "solve the problem" and gain political capital, politicians have jumped on the issue of gas prices with the conviction that they are the only power that can truly curb demand. Rather than relying market forces, they craft legislative plans to "cut future US gasoline demand and improve the fuel economy of cars and trucks" (see Harry Reid's and Nancy Pelosi's comments at CNN).

The political message is clear: in order to save Americans from the painful choice of using less gas or sending more of their money to the companies that actually make the gas, the politicians are going to make Americans use less gas and send more of their money to Washington.

Wednesday, May 9, 2007

Business and the Liberal Arts

Many business people view the liberal arts -- here defined as the study of literature, history, and languages -- as nearly useless knowledge. If not useless, than at least not practical. They ask, "Aren't there more valuable returns on subjects like accounting and engineering?" Or, as one recently spied tee-shirt put it, "Friends don't let friends major in liberal arts."


We can draw a valuable lesson from -- surprise -- history. The French Revolution violently swept away the old system of learning and replaced it with schools that taught almost exclusively scientific subjects. The test of the educated man was no longer his knowledge of history, Greek or Latin, but his knowledge of mathematics, chemistry, physics and natural history. Education became, in a word, "scientific."

What was the result?

In his 1952 book, The Counter Revolution of Science, Friedrich Hayek summarized what happened in France:

"Thus, a whole generation grew up to whom that great storehouse of social wisdom, the only form indeed in which an understanding of the social processes achieved by the greatest minds is transmitted, the great literature of all ages, was a closed book. For the first time in history that new type appeared which as the the product of the German Reaschule and of similar institutions was to become so important and influential in the later nineteenth and the twentieth century: the technical specialist who was regarded as educated because he had passed through difficult schools but who had little or no knowledge of society, its life, growth , problems and values, which only the study of history, literature and languages can give."

An emphasis on scientific knowledge and the deliberate exclusion of the liberal arts led to mis-guided attempts to apply scientific terminology and methods to historical and social analysis. As a result, French science went from being foremost in the world to middle of the pack, and French social thought paved the way for totalitarianism in the name of science and the immutable laws of history.

Tuesday, May 8, 2007

The Old Whig: F. A. Hayek's Birthday


Today, 8 May, is the birthday of one of the great intellectuals of the 20th century, F. A. Hayek (1899 - 1992).

Hayek consistently championed the spontaneous order of free individuals over the conscious order of Utopian social scientists.

In The Road to Serfdom in 1944, he succinctly stated the economic and moral case for free markets:

"Economic liberalism....regards competition as superior not only because it is in most circumstances the most efficient method known but even more because it is the only method by which our activities can be adjusted to each other without coercive or arbitrary intervention of authority. Indeed, one of the main arguments in favor of competition is that it dispenses with the need for 'conscious social control' and that it gives the individuals a chance to decide whether the prospects of a particular occupation are sufficient to compensate for the disadvantages and risks connected with it."

Hayek did not like to hear his views described as "conservative," "classical liberal," or "libertarian." He suggested the description "old whig." Pity it never caught on.

Monday, May 7, 2007

Free Trade



An article by Kerry Howley in the May 2007 edition of Reason magazine asks the question "Who Supports Free Trade?"


The answer? According to a survey from the Pew Research Center for the People & the Press, "Better educated and more affluent Americans, regardless of party, generally view free trade more positively."


Free trade is not the captive issue of any political party. Free trade is simply consistent with human nature and the social institutions humans have developed to increase their odds of survival and happiness.


Free trade is one of those rare issues where the right and the left can agree. As the world grows more affluent and better educated, popular support for free trade will grow, too. However, free trade always faces a threat from a small but vocal segment of the population, and from politicians willing to pander to that segment. For example, the Bush steel tariffs. With friends like these, who needs enemies?

Sunday, May 6, 2007

Business as Usual

HUGO CHAVEZ’S TO-DO LIST

  1. Nationalize electricity business √
  2. Nationalize healthcare business √
  3. Nationalize banking business √
  4. Nationalize mining industry √
  5. Nationalize oil industry √
  6. Nationalize gas business √
  7. Nationalize telecommunication business √
  8. Nationalize steel business √
  9. Blame international big business for ruining the lives of the people √
  10. Call Barney Frank. Compare lists. √

Saturday, May 5, 2007

Business School Prof Says Business Destroys the Soul


Dr. Pritam Singh, a Senior Lecturer in Economics at the Oxford Brooks University School of Business, must think of himself as a missionary among heathens.

Either that, or he is a hypocrite.

In a letter to the The Financial Times of London on 27 April 2007, under the title "Commodification of Life is What Robs Capitalism of its Soul," Dr. Singh wrote:

"The growing body of academic literature on the crying need for business ethics is a manifestation of the essentially unethical and soul-destroying nature of modern businesses..."

How long will his students stay in business if they believe they are acting unethically and destroying souls? How successful does he expect them to be, burdened with the belief that business is a crime?

Friday, May 4, 2007

John Blundell at the Bastiat Society

John Blundell, Director General of the Institute of Economic Affairs (IEA) in London, spoke to the Bastiat Society on 2 May 2007.

His topic was "Achieving Change: What We Learned from Margaret Thatcher."

During her tenure as Prime Minister, the UK went from being a political and economic mess to being a model of free market governance.

The Iron Lady left a legacy that continued long after she left office. Consider the difference in these measures of economic health between 1979, when she first came to office, and 1997, when New Labour triumphed:

  1. The middle class as % of the population went from 33% to 50%.
  2. Home owners as a % went from 53% to 71%.
  3. Share owners as a % went from 7% to 23%.
  4. Trade unionists who are share owners as a % went from 6% to 29%.
  5. Days lost to strikes per anum went from 30M to 1/2M.
  6. The % of workers self-employed went from 7% to 14% (current).
  7. The % of workers in a trade union went from 51% to 19%.

How did she do this? John offers ten lessons from "The Book of Margaret:"

  1. Govern with a strong moral compass.
  2. Simplify and communicate with conviction.
  3. Lead but always listen.
  4. Use policies consistent with human nature.
  5. Think about strategy ahead of time.
  6. Build a good team.
  7. Use circumstances.
  8. Make good allies.
  9. Prepare for power when you don't have it.
  10. Have patience.

In the words of John Blundell, "The story of Margaret Thatcher is the extraordinary story of a country saving itself."

Thursday, May 3, 2007

What is the Bastiat Society?

The Bastiat Society is named after the great French economist, Frederic Bastiat. Bastiat was famous for making complex ideas easy to understand.

One topic widely misunderstood today is the morality of business. While businesses compete to feed, clothe, shelter, entertain and empower individuals of every age, occupation and nation, academics, intellectuals, popular artists and ambitious politicians portray business people as villains or buffoons.

It is time for business people to counterattack these gross distortions of the truth.

The Bastiat Society proclaims the productive, humane, and moral leadership of honest business people.