What might be wrong with judicial compassion and empathy? John Hasnas writes in the Wall Street Journal...
"Frederic Bastiat answered that question in his famous 1850 essay, "What is Seen and What is Not Seen." There the economist and member of the French parliament pointed out that law "produces not only one effect, but a series of effects. Of these effects, the first alone is immediate; it appears simultaneously with its cause; it is seen. The other effects emerge only subsequently; they are not seen; we are fortunate if we foresee them." Bastiat further noted that "[t]here is only one difference between a bad economist and a good one: The bad economist confines himself to the visible effect; the good economist takes into account both the effect that can be seen and those effects that must be foreseen."
This observation is just as true for judges as it is for economists. As important as compassion and empathy are, one can have these feelings only for people that exist and that one knows about -- that is, for those who are "seen."
One can have compassion for workers who lose their jobs when a plant closes. They can be seen. One cannot have compassion for unknown persons in other industries who do not receive job offers when a compassionate government subsidizes an unprofitable plant. The potential employees not hired are unseen."
Sunday, May 31, 2009
Judicial Compassion and Empathy
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
6:52 AM
0
comments
Labels: Bastiat
Saturday, May 30, 2009
Powerful and Secure
Every ruling class wants to enjoy feeling powerful and secure. This usually means power over others, and security at someone else's expense.
Once a ruling class feels powerful and secure, it will not relinquish either its power or its security without a fight. Sometimes it will fight with words, sometimes with fists, sometimes with vast armies, but it will always fight.
It will use public money to defend its private advantages. It will call on the intellectual community to provide justifications and, when necessary, mythologies to defend its actions. Finally, as a ruling power, it will use its police and armies in the name of law and order to harass, imprison, and destroy its opposition. A threatened ruling class is the one of the most dangerous things on earth.
Consider the American Civil War. The ruling class of the Old South depended on slavery for its feelings of power and security. From the beginning of the United States, the South did not stop using words and violence to justify, preserve, and expand slavery, until it was humiliated by a military defeat, exhausted by war, and economically crushed by uncompensated emancipation. In short, the ruling class of the Old South refused to surrender its power and security until they were taken from its cold dead hand.
The price of this defeat is staggering. Over 600,000 citizens died, a vast region of the country lay impoverished for a century, and bitterness and humiliation led directly to a political legacy of racism enshrined in law.
History provides us a stark warning, for today we exist under a new generation of the ruling class. This one lives in Washington, DC, the last boom town in America. It believes with all the fervor of an ante-bellum slave owner that it is leading a less-enlightened population down the path of civilization and progress. Towards that goal, it is justified in all that it does, from taxation, to regulation, to fines, punishment, and imprisonment. It is the modern equivalent of the Master. We are the modern equivalent of the property it governs for our own good.
Like all ruling classes, ours will attempt to characterize any opposition as ill-informed, misguided, irrational, delusional, dangerous, disloyal, treasonous, or evil. But the opposition is not the dangerous group here. In fact, simple humanity means that we should be pulling for those who object to being treated like human inferiors. We should hope that they will win this fight with words. The consequences of losing are too terrible to imagine.
The goal of the good society should never be class power or class security. That simply creates a group of especially dangerous people willing to set the world aflame rather than surrender their position. The goal of the good society should be individual power, what used to be called autonomy or individual liberty.
In liberty, every individual is free to seek as much or as little security as he or she sees fit, and no group of individuals can insist on dragging the rest of us through another Götterdämmerung.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
8:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Social Theory
Wednesday, May 27, 2009
The Bastiat Prize for Online Journalism
The Bastiat Prize for Online Journalism is awarded to journalists who defend the principles of the free society with wit and vigour.
Judges have included Milton Friedman and Margaret Thatcher. For the first time this year, there is an additional $3,000 prize for online journalism to recognise the role of bloggers and others in promoting freedom through their writing.
Get the full details of this year's competition at: www.bastiatprize.org.
The Bastiat Prize is sponsored by the International Policy Network, and is not affiliated with the Bastiat Society.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
8:24 AM
0
comments
Labels: Social Theory
Tuesday, May 26, 2009
Corporate Sellouts
"Communist Godfather Vladimir Lenin is alleged to have famously said, "The capitalists will sell us the rope with which we will hang them.
Nowhere is that observation more relevant than in the sorry spectacle taking place in Congress as corporations, in exchange for short-term government handouts, fall over themselves to endorse a carbon dioxide regulation bill that will impose a crushing energy tax on the American people."
From "Corporate Sellouts" in The American Spectator.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
8:37 AM
0
comments
Labels: Business
Monday, May 25, 2009
Corporate Sanction
The National Journal reports, "key business interests have decided to cut deals with a dominant Democratic Party rather than bet on a weakened Republican Party that is hoping to ride uncompromising opposition to Obama back to power. "You've got business that has sometimes opposed everything Democrats have done lining up to help get it done," White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel said."
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
6:16 AM
0
comments
Labels: Business
Sunday, May 24, 2009
Leave the Economists at Home
Via Organizations and Markets, evidence that business is alive and well as long as it leaves the economists at home.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
10:09 AM
0
comments
Labels: Humor
Saturday, May 23, 2009
A Good Explanation
"Human beings are as good at devising ex post facto explanations for big disasters as they are bad at anticipating those disasters. It is indeed impressive how rapidly the economists who failed to predict this crisis — or predicted the wrong crisis (a dollar crash) — have been able to produce such a satisfying story about its origins. Yes, it was all the fault of deregulation."
Niall Ferguson writing in the New York Times
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
9:42 AM
0
comments
Labels: Social Theory
USA, Double A Credit
SR Rating, a Brazilian firm, will soon issue a judgment on American government bonds. Its verdict is not pretty: the company says it will issue a AA rating.
From The Economist.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Friday, May 22, 2009
The Briefing Book
"If there's one thing worse than being governed by Nancy Pelosi and Harry Reid and a bunch of idiot Republicans, it's being governned by our neighbors who have brain farts and write email letters to the president."
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
8:37 AM
1 comments
Labels: Politics
Monday, May 18, 2009
The Great Ethanol Scam
"Not only is ethanol proving to be a dud as a fuel substitute but there is increasing evidence that it is destroying engines in large numbers."
From Business Week.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
6:58 AM
0
comments
Labels: Environmentalism
Sunday, May 17, 2009
A New Foundation
What does the economic policy of a New Foundation look like?
Higher taxes
More regulation
Attacks on business
Illegal takings
Limits on compensation
A brewing trade war with Canada
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Politics
Saturday, May 16, 2009
Obama Attacks Business
"Relations between President Barack Obama and U.S. corporate leaders have grown tense in recent weeks, with business groups bristling over his sharp rebukes of lenders and multinational companies in particular."
Read the rest here.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Business
Friday, May 15, 2009
The Stand Up Economist
Stand-Up Economist Yoram Bauman:
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Humor
Thursday, May 14, 2009
A Savior-Based Economy
CNN's John King interviews South Carolina Governor Mark Sanford.
The Governor warns, “We’re moving precipitously close to what I would call a savior-based economy....what you see in Russia or Venezuela or Zimbabwe or places like that where it matters not how good your product is to the consumer but what your political connection is to those in power.”
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
6:52 AM
0
comments
Labels: Politics
Wednesday, May 13, 2009
An Assault on Business
US News wonders, "Another week, another assault on business-as-usual by President Obama. Or is it, as some critics are starting to wonder, an assault on business, as usual?"
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
9:14 PM
0
comments
Labels: Business
Sunday, May 10, 2009
Thus Ended Capitalism
Today's Dilbert is too good to be missed. Click on the strip below to see it in its entirety.
View more capitalist humor at the official Dilbert website.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
10:10 AM
0
comments
Labels: Humor
Saturday, May 9, 2009
State and Corporation
"The function of the state -- to record the creation of corporations -- is not essential to their existence any more than the registrar of births is essential to the conception or birth of a child.
This mere procedural requirement of filing the articles with a state official is equated with state creation. Procedural requirements, though, are not unique to corporations. On the contrary, procedural requirements apply to virtually all contracts. For example, to be legally valid, a marriage contract must follow specified procedural requirements: it must be performed by someone authorized by the state, it must be witnessed, and a signed certificate must be filed with the state If these requirements make the state a party to a contract, then every marriage is a menage a trois: bride, groom, and government. Quite literally, the government plays a smaller role in the creation of a corporation than of a marriage. Yet who, for that reason, would describe marriage as a creature of the state or claim that a marriage certificate contains a promise to serve the public interest?"
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Social Theory
Friday, May 8, 2009
It Cannot Happen Here
Over at Cafe Hayek, they commemorate the anniversary of F. A. Hayek's birth by recalling the opening paragraph of one of his chapters, "Totalitarians in Our Midst," published in 1944:
"Probably it is true that the very magnitude of the outrages committed by the totalitarian governments, instead of increasing the fear that such a system might one day arise in more enlightened countries, has rather strengthened the assurance that it cannot happen here.... But let us not forget that fifteen years ago the possibility of such a thing happening in Germany would have appeared just as fantastic, not only to nine-tenths of the Germans themselves, but also to the most hostile foreign observers (however wise they may now pretend to have been)."
From The Road to Serfdom. View an illustrated version here.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
8:07 AM
0
comments
Labels: Social Theory
Thursday, May 7, 2009
No Shame
I guess it is too much to expect any politician -- even a disgraced one -- to resist the federal open hunting season on banks and bankers.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
1:53 PM
0
comments
Labels: Politics
Wednesday, May 6, 2009
May 2009 Meeting

Dr. Eric Daniels is the speaker for our May 2009 monthly meeting.
Dr. Daniels is a Research Assistant Professor at Clemson University's Institute for the Study of Capitalism. He previously served as a postdoctoral fellow and visiting assistant professor at Duke University's Program on Values and Ethics in the Marketplace, where he was nominated for a teaching award. In addition, Daniels has taught at the University of Wisconsin, where he earned his doctorate in American history. He has lectured internationally on the history of American ethics, American business and entrepreneurship, and the American Enlightenment. He has appeared on C-SPAN's "American Writers" series and his articles have appeared in the Atlanta Journal-Constitution and the San Diego Business Journal. Daniels's other publications include a chapter in The Abolition of Antitrust and five entries in the Oxford Companion to United States History. Most recently, he co-authored the U.S. Economic Freedom Index, 2008 Report.
View a pdf of the Report here.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
8:14 AM
0
comments
Labels: Meetings
