Tuesday, July 31, 2007
Monday, July 30, 2007
Where Things Look Worse
Americans are well-known optimists. Or they used to be.
Reviewing the results of the Pew Global Attitudes Project, Michael Barone writes in the National Review that "...only 25 percent of Americans are positive about the direction of the nation, down from 41 percent in 2002. In only a handful of the 47 nations are there declines of similar magnitude — Uganda, the Czech Republic, France, Canada, and Italy."
It is understandable that the people in Uganda are not optimistic about the direction of their country, although it's hard to imagine things there getting worse. In France, pessimism is chic. It makes one sound intellectual, cosmopolitan, and very un-American. Barone surmises that the other three countries are on the list due to nasty political fights in Prague, Ottawa and Rome. That is probably true for the US, as well.
The common thread in all four capitals is the popular expectation that political action is appropriate and necessary to solve most of the problems in life, whether international, national or personal. When you expect government to solve all the problems in the world, from terrorism to telemarketing, you'll naturally be disappointed when the political system seizes up.
Meanwhile, politicians gain office by recasting everything as a political problem and claiming they have the political solution. Then they stay in office by blaming their political enemies for lack of progress. Considering the unrealistic expectations of the voters, the exaggerated claims of the politicians, and the inevitable disappointing results, it is no wonder that so many people are gloomy about their nation's future.
Only when citizens realize that it is a bad idea to demand political solutions for every inconvenience in life will they enjoy a renewed sense of optimism. Optimism requires faith in the future and a sense of control over one's destiny. Politics cannot reliably deliver either one. If anything, blind faith in politics leads to frustration and despair.
Pessimistic about politics. That's the most realistic view of all.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
8:34 AM
0
comments
Labels: Politics
Sunday, July 29, 2007
The Basic Needs of Citizens
Who or what should be responsible for providing the basic needs of citizens?
If you answered "the government," you have some illustrious company, none other than Mikhail Gorbachev, the last president of the former Soviet Union. In an interview in Pravda, he said:
"...the government should satisfy the basic needs of the citizens – that’s a top priority. If authoritarianism is required to do the job, I’m ready to give my full support to this kind of authoritarianism."
In an unrelated but ironic development, Gorbachev appears in an advertising campaign for luxury luggage maker Louis Vuitton. Perhaps Louis Vuitton luggage is one of those basic needs, at least for those citizens who are more equal than others.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
1:49 PM
0
comments
Labels: Politics
Saturday, July 28, 2007
SC Premier of "Mine Your Own Business"
The South Carolina premier of Mine Your Own Business, a documentary about the dark side of environmentalism, will be shown at the American Theater in Downtown Charleston in September.
The Bastiat Society is offering the controversial documentary by Phelim McAleer and Ann McElhinne to the public, free of charge.
The film will be shown at the American Theatre, 446 King Street in Charleston on Wednesday, September 5th, 2007 at 5 pm.
“Move over Michael Moore. You have competition in the art of political film making…but instead of advancing the cause of smug liberal hypocrisy, he’s [McAleer] debunking it.” – Wall Street Journal Online.
Space is limited.
RSVP to: Stephanie Whitener
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
9:05 AM
0
comments
Labels: Meetings
Friday, July 27, 2007
When Traders Get Things Right
One of the best books on business is "When Genius Failed" by Roger Lowenstein. It is the the story of the spectacular and scary 1998 blow-up of the hedge fund Long Term Capital Management.
Although the book focuses on the financial markets, it offers lessons for business in general. My favorite passage:
"Even when traders get things 'right,' markets can hardly be expected to oscillate with the precision of sine waves. Prices and spreads vary with the uncertain progress of companies, governments, and even civilizations. They are no more certain than the societies whose economic activity they reflect. Dice are predictable down to the decimal point; Russia is not; how traders will respond to Russia is less predictable still. Unlike dice, markets are subject not merely to risk, an arithmetic concept, but also to the broader uncertainty that shadows the future generally. Unfortunately, uncertainty, as opposed to risk, is an indefinite condition, one that does not conform to numerical straight jackets."
The broader business moral in the story of Long Term Capital Management is that the world is far less stable and predictable than we care to admit. Finance and accounting make the world manageable, but they do not necessarily make the world more predictable. This is true because finance and accounting are themselves a subset of the way the human mind sorts through large seas of data in search of signficant details, a process science defines as cognition.
Cognition creates a sense of order in the universe that is tremendously useful for accomplishing many tasks. But it is dangerous to assume that that particular sense of order is all there is, or that it will capture all the significant details, or that it will remain permanently useful.
Cognition is like a map. A map is useful because of what it includes, and because of what it leaves out. When circumstances change, it can be worthless for the same reasons.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
9:53 AM
0
comments
Labels: Business
Thursday, July 26, 2007
"To the Use of Merchants"
The Antwerp Bourse (from the Latin bursa, or purse) was one of the world's first securities exchanges. It opened for business in the 16th century. It's motto is as good today as it was then: "To the use of merchants of every land and tongue."
Business is not about patriotism, language, or religion. People who live in different countries, who don't speak the same language, and who don't worship in the same place can peacefully do business together, to their mutual satisfaction.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:37 AM
0
comments
Labels: Business
Wednesday, July 25, 2007
Power, Corruption, and Success
Great myths are always about us, and about somewhere else.
The tales of Harry Potter offer us universal morals about power, corruption and success. They offer them through the lens of a young boy with British sensibilities, coming of age in the modern United Kingdom. He is also a wizard, locked in a life-or-death battle with relentless evil.
Some French intellectuals deconstructed the texts of the Harry Potter phenomenon in search of grander – or more menacing – conclusions. No surprise, they found them. Equally no surprise, they don’t agree.
Perhaps their high-brow criticism has something to do with J. K. Rowling's less-than-flattering portrayal of the French wizard school, Beauxbatons, in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire. Or, perhaps they cannot admit that it might be a harmless thing that something as quintessentially British as Harry Potter is so popular all over the world, even in France. Or maybe it has been so long since some French intellectuals actually witnessed a market economy satisfying human needs that they have a hard time believing in one, even in a work of fantasy. Regardless of their motives, they have concluded that Harry Potter represents everything from a ruthless capitalist to a crusading antiglobalist.
The truth is, the world of Harry Potter is first and foremost British. His school, its students, their social priorities, their names, and even their slang make the world of Harry Potter irresistibly British.
Britain provides the place, the launching point of the mythic enterprise, the sense of somewhere else. But the morals of the story are universal. Lord Acton famously observed, "Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely.” In Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, the just released movie based on the earlier book, corrupt power is immediately on display. In almost the first scene, two dark creatures under the control of a government agency, the Ministry of Magic, attack and nearly kill Harry and his cousin, Dudley.
In order to save their lives, Harry performs a difficult magic spell. He is successful, but instead of being praised as a hero, he is stunned to learn that he might lose his wand and be kicked out of school for breaking wizarding laws.
The Minister of Magic, Cornelius Fudge, is corrupt, power-hungry, self-righteous and paranoid. He wants to get Harry out of the way as quickly as possible. Fudge plants a spy in Harry’s school, Dolores Umbridge. She is sadistic and inflexible. She imposes rule after rule to suppress non-conformists, until she assumes complete control of the school. She is willing to use torture to get what she wants.
Fudge and Umbridge illustrate just how power corrupts. But there is a far more sinister kind of power in the story. It is the essence of evil, an evil beyond redemption, and an evil without remorse. It is the evil of Lord Voldemort.
Some critics have concluded that Voldemort represents the logical end of a market economy, where success is measured solely by personal gain. This line of thinking has gone so far as to turn Volemort’s name into “Waldemart,” a combination of Wal-Mart and Voldemort. If Voldemort is a capitalist icon, then Harry Potter must be an anticapitalist hero. This would conveniently explain why Harry’s sensibilities are entirely different from the clean car and kitchen-scrubbing values of his middle-class aunt and uncle.
But this is an incorrect conclusion. Harry's distaste for the middle-class reveals more about British cultural ambivalence than mythic moral values. Remember that the world of Harry Potter is unfailingly British, and modern British culture has decidedly mixed feelings about middle-class business success. On one hand, British citizens enjoy the productivity and personal freedom of the market-based government reforms brought about by Margaret Thatcher and her Conservative successor from 1975 to 1997. On the other hand, they have grown used to the anti-business rhetoric and social welfare system of various Labour governments over the past sixty years. J. K. Rowling simply conveys the background noise of ambivalence about markets from the real world to the fictional world of Harry Potter.
There is no antiglobalist economic moral in Harry’s epic battle with Voldemort, any more than there is an economic moral in his regular arguments with his aunt and uncle. There is, however, an unresolved class conflict within the cultural context of the story, but it comes from the British lens Rowling uses to draw us into her myth, not the myth itself. It is a mistake to draw antiglobalist economic morals from a story that deals with economics only tangentially.
Indeed, although it doesn’t figure prominently in the story, economics doesn’t come off too badly in the Harry Potter tales. In fact, it comes off better than the aristocracy or bureaucracy, both of which are frequently in league with Voldemort. Harry’s fellow students demonstrate a familiar set of youthful wants and wishes, the kind that are often criticized as being shallow, but the kind often satisfied by exchanges in a competitive market economy. They want to date, they buy lots of candy and butter beer, they want to be good at sports, they want to do well in school, they buy books and magazines, they want to own the best wands, brooms and robes, they enjoy receiving gifts, and they want a job when they graduate. While some of these may be shallow interests compared with lofty morals, they cannot be honestly called precursors of evil. They are normal human desires, best satisfied by peaceful, voluntary behavior. Markets do that. It’s almost magic.
In the final analysis, Harry Potter is neither a ruthless capitalist nor an antiglobalist crusader. He does not seek success as measured by the market. He does not seek success as measured by social status. Rather, Harry Potter seeks success as measured by universal morals of power, corruption, and success. With him, we learn first that power is dangerous and must be used responsibly if it is to be used at all. Second, we learn that we must resist corruption, but never mistake blind obedience to a set of rules for virtue. Finally, we learn to measure the success of our lives by love and friendship more than anything else.
Those are values every muggle in the world can appreciate. Even French ones.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
2:37 PM
2
comments
Labels: Business
Monday, July 23, 2007
Tax that Guy Behind the Tree
Don't tax you.
Don't tax me.
Tax that guy
Behind the tree.
That little bit of doggerel popped into mind when I saw a headline in the Financial Times about a global backlash against globalization. The article stated, "In response to fears of globalisation and rising inequality, the public in all the rich countries surveyed – the US, Germany, UK, France, Italy and Spain – want their governments to increase taxation on those with the highest incomes. "
If the public had been asked, "Do you think we should increase your taxes?" I'm sure they would have come up with a different but no less confident conclusion. Even better, we should have asked them point blank, "Are you rich?"
In the United States for 2004, to be in the top 1 percent of adjusted gross income (AGI), you needed to earn $309,160, according to Arnold Kling at Econlib.
An awful lot of working couples and small business people make more than $309,160. They don't think of themselves as rich. Comfortable, maybe, but not rich. But of course, a campaign to "tax the comfortable" wouldn't get very far.
Beware those who want to "tax the rich." They may be talking about you.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
12:25 PM
0
comments
Labels: Politics
Sunday, July 22, 2007
What Makes Business Possible
Humans like to trade. Business is hard-wired in human nature.
So why are some groups better at it than others? Why do some nations grow rich on business, while others remain desperately poor?
All too often, people have tried to explain differences in wealth by the accidents of geography, race, or nature. The truth is, success or failure in trade is based on capital, and capital is based on law. The Peruvian economist Hernando DeSoto addressed this issue in his book, The Mystery of Capital.
For example, I can get a loan from a bank because I own my house. How does my banker know that I own it? Because there is a reliable system of law that converts the physical property of my house into a socially acceptable representation of it called a deed. The same reliable system of law allows me to convert that deed into another form of capital, a loan. I can then use that loan for another round of wealth creation.
In most of the world, poor people own property, but they can't prove it. Not being able to prove it, they can't get a loan against it. Without a loan, they can't engage in a new round of wealth creation.
In short, wealth begins with ownership. It expands as the legal system makes it easier and more reliable to demonstrate ownership.
A reliable legal system is the key to creating wealth through trade. And secure property rights are the key to a reliable legal system.
The following video features Hernando DeSoto discussing some of his work.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
8:46 AM
0
comments
Labels: Business
Saturday, July 21, 2007
Hammer & Tickle
The following is a bit of Soviet-era humor from Ben Lewis, who wrote "Hammer & Tickle" for Prospect magazine, and produced the documentary of the same name. The documentary trailer appears below.
A man dies and goes to hell. There he discovers that he has a choice: he can go to capitalist hell or to communist hell. Naturally, he wants to compare the two, so he goes over to capitalist hell.
There outside the door is the devil, who looks a bit like Ronald Reagan. "What's it like in there?" asks the visitor. "Well," the devil replies, "in capitalist hell, they flay you alive, then they boil you in oil and then they cut you up into small pieces with sharp knives.""That's terrible!" he gasps. "I'm going to check out communist hell!"
He goes over to communist hell, where he discovers a huge queue of people waiting to get in. He waits in line. Eventually he gets to the front and there at the door to communist hell is a little old man who looks a bit like Karl Marx. "
I'm still in the free world, Karl," he says, "and before I come in, I want to know what it's like in there." "In communist hell," says Marx impatiently, "they flay you alive, then they boil you in oil, and then they cut you up into small pieces with sharp knives.""But… but that's the same as capitalist hell!" protests the visitor, "Why such a long queue?"
"Well," sighs Marx, "Sometimes we're out of oil, sometimes we don't have knives, sometimes no hot water…"
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:29 AM
0
comments
Labels: Humor
Friday, July 20, 2007
Harry Potter, Businessman?
A French intellectual has deconstructed the texts of the Harry Potter phenomenon in search of its deeper meaning.
The result? The world of Harry Potter is a capitalist universe. Depending on your view of business, Harry is either a business superhero or a business super villain. Either way, Harry is more about the Market Order than the Order of the Phoenix.
Only a French intellectual could come up with a conclusion like that with a straight face. Anyone who has read the Harry Potter series knows that they contain no economic morals.
Harry Potter's most important moral is that we should measure success in love, friendship, and courage, not in money.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:59 AM
0
comments
Labels: Business
Thursday, July 19, 2007
How to Honor Fallen Fire Fighters
In June, nine firemen in
It goes without saying that everyone in
Business and commerce are the life blood of our city and it was a business that these men died protecting. It seems to me that using public funds to buy a commercial location and remove it from active commerce denigrates what these men did and what their remaining colleagues continue to do. It also sends a subliminal message that a site of commerce is not suitable as a memorial. However, business is a noble enterprise. It is from businesses that we get our medicine, clothes, food and other necessities of life. When we need a place to eat or spend the night it is total strangers engaged in commerce who fill our needs. It matters not that the providers’ motives may be their own self interest, we get served just the same. This is the genius of our capitalistic system. To suggest, even indirectly, that these activities should not continue at the site of the tragedy is to misunderstand both the nature of man and our society.
Meaning in no way to lessen what our fire fighters do for us, for they are indispensable in our community, those who take huge risks to start businesses that satisfy our needs and wants; fill our tax coffers; and create the jobs upon which our society depends are heroes also. Our fire fighters know this - that is why they fight so valiantly to protect our businesses.
So, a modest proposal – first, let’s build a memorial in a fitting public place. Additionally, let’s honor the sacrifice of those nine heroes by keeping commerce flowing in what is a commercial site in the middle of a commercial area. Yes, make sure a suitable plaque is installed on the new building that is constructed on that site; but let’s honor the fire fighter’s memory everyday by having everyday people honorably going about the business of delivering goods and services to our community. In that way the community will continue to reap the benefits of commerce, which those nine gave their lives to try and save. That would be a truly lasting tribute.
Posted by
Don McLaurin
at
7:28 AM
0
comments
Labels: Business
Wednesday, July 18, 2007
The Call of the Entrepreneur
"...how we view entrepreneurs—as greedy or altruistic, as virtuous or vicious—shapes the destinies of individuals and nations."
That is the message from the Acton Institute, in a new documentary worthy of attention, "The Call of the Entrepreneur."
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:07 AM
0
comments
Labels: Business
Tuesday, July 17, 2007
Jeremiah, Milton Friedman, and Liberty
On Wednesday, July 11, 2007, Bob Chitester was the speaker at the monthly meeting of the Bastiat Society. His topic was “Jeremiah, Milton Friedman, and Liberty.”
Some excerpts from his comments follow:
Milton Friedman was a modern Jeremiah. His God, if you will, was liberty. The citizens of the United States had a covenant with freedom, in which they had lost faith. He was determined to sound the alarm. He never concerned himself with what others would think of him.
***
Freedom is not at the top of business leaders’ agenda, although they profess otherwise.
***
Freedom is not at the top of politicians’ agenda although they profess otherwise.
***
Have any of you stood up and said it’s immoral -- taxing workers struggling to make their own mortgage payments, to help a few business people ---- and advance some political careers? If there is a principle underlying these kinds of schemes it is one I do not wish to embrace.
***
People should be free to gamble if they wish, but the government should not be involved and communities should not be going out of their way to help establish gambling facilities.
***
If people are going hungry here in Charleston and around this nation, it is not because of lack of food. Even the federal government, who’s own “food bank” effort - food stamps – has been operating for decades, admits that the greatest health problem among poorer members of our society is obesity.
***
My passion and the goal of Free to Choose Media, izzit.org and The Idea Channel, is to relate economic freedom, personal freedom, individual freedom and the rule of law to peoples’ personal experience. Our first goal is to make school age children aware of the power of voluntary association and the rule of law to make the world a happier place for all people. Creating awareness of these fundamental values in the next generation of citizens must be part of any effort “save the Republic.”
***
Driven by rigorous logic, the use of rhetorical tools through mass media is essential to preserving liberty in a democratic society.
***
Don’t use government to force citizens to pay for services they would not freely support. Resist others who want to do so.
***
The wealth created by economic freedom is a necessary but not sufficient condition for a better life. We must not forget, or let others forget, that free markets provide not only material well being but the time to explore our inner visions of the beautiful and profound.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
3:07 PM
0
comments
Labels: Meetings
Monday, July 16, 2007
Stumbling on Happiness
Stephen Colbert interviews Daniel Gilbert, the author of Stumbling on Happiness. You'll be astonished to learn that marriage makes people happier than money.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:53 AM
0
comments
Labels: Wealth
Sunday, July 15, 2007
Business and the Good Samaritan
Today, Catholics everywhere will once again hear the story of the Good Samaritan from the Gospel of Luke. It is one of the world's most famous parables.
In the time of Christ, Jews and Samaritans were bitter enemies, each considering the other heretical. The idea of a Samaritan helping a wounded Jew would have been unsettling. Even more disturbing would have been the fact that the two other orthodox Jews in the story, a priest and a Levite, ignored the suffering of their kinsman.
There are many lessons we can draw from this parable. For people in business -- that is to say, for anyone involved in the process of wealth creation -- one of the most important lessons comes from Margaret Thatcher, Prime Minister of the United Kingdom from 1979 to 1990.
In a 1987 speech to Scottish Conservatives, Thatcher observed, "No one would remember the Good Samaritan if he'd only had good intentions. He had money as well."
Wealth makes charity possible. The creation of more wealth makes even more charity possible.
One other person in this parable is often overlooked. He is the unnamed innkeeper who took in the wounded Jew, and extended the Good Samaritan credit for the Jew's care. The innkeeper was not acting charitably, but the resulting business arrangement made him an important player in the Samaritan's charitable effort.
Business and charity are not the same thing, and it is a mistake to make them act like they are. But they can work well together towards the same end when each acts according to its strength and purpose.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
9:49 AM
0
comments
Labels: Business, Philanthropy, Religion
Chad Waldorff at Bastiat in August
Chad Waldorff, the Chairman of the South Carolina Club for Growth, will be the speaker at the August monthly meeting of the Bastiat Society.
"Putting Sound Economics Into Politics"
Date: Wednesday, 1 August 2007
Hors d'oeuvres : 5:00 pm
Speaker: 6:00 pm
Location: Imaging Arts Gallery 175 King Street, Charleston, SC
RSVP to Stephanie Whitener
Chad’s first government experience came when he took a year off from college to serve in President Reagan’s Office of Political Affairs. After the 1988 election cycle, Chad left the White House to return to the University of Virginia. Shortly after graduating, he and two high school friends moved to Mount Pleasant to create the first Sticky Fingers restaurant.
Their original concept has grown to over 1000 employees in their sixteen restaurants, catering, mail order, and wholesale businesses. Chad and his partners have been named Ernst and Young “Entrepreneurs of the Year” for the Carolinas as well as the Lowcountry’s “Most Philanthropic Company.”
In 2003 Chad took a two-year sabbatical from his business to serve as a Deputy Chief of Staff to Governor Mark Sanford. It was largely through that experience of seeing sound fiscal policy fall prey to legislative gamesmanship that lead to his current involvement with the South Carolina Club for Growth.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:00 AM
0
comments
Labels: Meetings
Saturday, July 14, 2007
Stossel Teaches Bill Gates A Business Lesson
ABC News anchor and 20/20 correspondent John Stossel, one of the few people on television who appreciate the productive and ethical wonders of competition, had a business lesson for Bill Gates after the Microsoft billionaire spoke at Harvard in June.
In his speech, Gates lamented the suffering of the world's poor who have "no power in the market and no voice in the system." Stossel responded that the solution to poverty and human suffering is not philanthropy or blanket criticism of markets:
"Gates faults the free market for problems caused by governments. What constricts the reach of the free market is the state. Gates seems oblivious to all the ways that governments here and abroad cripple enterprise. In poor countries, corrupt bureaucracies smother entrepreneurship while enriching cronies. The lack of formal property rights and stable law keeps average people from accumulating capital. So the poor stay poor. That's what causes "scarcity of clean water" and kills 'children who die from diseases we can cure.'"
People are not poor because of lack of charity. They are not poor because markets make them poor. They are poor because their governments do not protect their lives, their property and their freedom to trade.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
8:15 AM
0
comments
Labels: Business, Philanthropy
Friday, July 13, 2007
Bad for Business
When is a tax break bad for business?
When it goes to your competition and not to you, too. That's playing favorites with the tax code, and it's a game politicians play all too well.
It's especially bad when it's big business getting the tax break, and small business paying the taxes. That's worse than robbing Peter to pay Paul. It's more like robbing David to pay Goliath. And it's exactly what the South Carolina Legislature is going to do. Surprise, surprise.
Governor Sanford vetoed a bill that gave big box retailers a tax break. The Governor said, correctly, that the bill did "what we should never do to small businesses in our state—it takes their money to subsidize a large corporate competitor that could well put them out of business.”
The Legislature, however, disagreed. It overrode his veto, and big business got what it wanted. The little guy got the bill.
This isn't free enterprise. It's a free for all. In the scramble for political favors, big business has most of the advantages, and ends up with most of the loot.
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
3:14 PM
0
comments
Thursday, July 12, 2007
Sowell on Money
A couple of thoughts on money from Thomas Sowell, Rose and Milton Friedman Fellow at the Hoover Institution at Stanford University.
"A month doesn’t go by without several offers to lend me money arriving in the mail. Where were these people when I was broke?"
"Many people who have never run one business for one day are nevertheless confident that they know corporate CEOs are not worth as much as they are paid."
Posted by
Ben Asa Rast
at
7:04 AM
0
comments

